Source Newsroom: Baylor University
Newswise — Pastor burnout — a trend that has led many ministers to leave their posts — has in recent years spurred everything from clergy health initiatives to sabbaticals to pastor burnout blogs.
But a number of seminaries are undertaking preventive medicine of the spiritual kind, which can play a significant role in overcoming future burnout, says the director of spiritual formation at Baylor University’s George W. Truett Theological Seminary.
“If we don’t attend to these things in seminary, we’re not setting our students up for ministry over the long haul,” said Angela Reed, Ph.D., an assistant professor of practical theology at Truett and author of Quest for Spiritual Community: Reclaiming Spiritual Guidance for Contemporary Congregations.
Truett and some other theological schools have turned to covenant groups and other spiritual formation programs aimed not only at building peer support and spiritual growth in seminary, but for years afterward.
“Increasingly, seminaries are going to specific programs,” said Daniel Aleshire, executive director of The Association of Theological Schools in the United States and Canada, which has 270 members. Some have a tradition of one-on-one spiritual directors, he said.
While there is no guaranteed “inoculation against future burnout,” he said, “there’s a great body of evidence that good pastoral work is always supported by some kind of community where there is accountability, honesty and confidentiality. What’s said in the group stays there. It’s a safe place.
“This gives an opportunity to share the hard questions about their own spiritual life and ministry. It’s worth the time and effort to continue that once they’re away from the unique world of the seminary.”
In a demanding and sometimes lonely calling, that foundation can help pastors maintain physical and emotional health, resist affairs and unwise financial decisions, maintain strong family relationships — even cope with clashes with congregants, Reed said.
Statistics attest to the need to “minister to ministers.” Surveys of pastors done by The Fuller Institute, George Barna, Pastoral Care Inc., LifeWay Research and H.B. London Jr. reveal that:
• 90 percent of pastors report working between 55 to 75 hours a week
• 90 percent feel inadequately trained to cope with the ministry demands
• 50 percent feel unable to meet the demands of the job
• 55 percent say they are discouraged
• 70 percent do not have someone they consider a close friend
• 80 percent believe pastoral ministry has affected their families in a negative way.
The demands also can take a physical toll in stress-linked conditions. Research by Duke University of United Methodist clergy in North Carolina shows they have higher rates of obesity, hypertension and depression.
“They feel that they have to be perfect, that they can’t show weakness, admit to their personal shortcomings, have doubts about their faith,” Reed said. Pastors’ schedules are unpredictable, and many feel the need to be on call 24/7. In some churches, pastors even have taken on the role of CEO in addition to that of spiritual leader. (Baylor recently approved a joint master’s degree in divinity and business administration, blending theological and biblical preparation with business skills.)
“Honest, deep relationships with people whom they are not pastoring can help them stay in ministry,” Reed said. “And those relationships can make a huge difference not only for the pastor, but for the congregation, too.”
Reed, a graduate of Princeton Theological Seminary, knows what it’s like to be burned out. In her early 20s, she took a position as an assistant pastor at a Mennonite Church in Manitoba, Canada.
“I began with so much energy — attending sporting events for our youth, making calls to them at night, running committees, teaching and offering pastoral care,” she said. “I was working day and night, trying to be there for everybody.”
After about a year and a half, “I was starting to fade,” she said. “It hit me when I was in a grocery store. I saw someone from my church and found myself wanting to walk the other way . . . As my service time for others had grown, my personal time for myself and my relationship with God had shrunk.”
When a pastoral support team of two began to meet regularly with her, “it really helped to turn me around,” she said. “I started being very intentional about things like spiritual practices and spending time with my family.” About six months later, “I was in a different place – joyful, with a sense of purpose and balance in my personal life.”
At Truett, roughly 40 groups of six to eight members — usually composed of the same gender — form when students enter seminary and continue through their six semesters there. Members meet weekly and are given readings and assignments to help them develop spiritual disciplines to nurture relationships with God and others. They share everything from silent prayer to personal struggles and experiences with grief to keeping their priorities straight. The groups provide accountability for personal commitments students want to make about Sabbath-keeping, living faithfully and spending time with family and friends. Faculty members, including the dean, also meet regularly in covenant groups of their own.
Kevin Miner of Angleton, a second-year seminary student at Truett who leads a covenant group, he values the trust, confidentiality and encouragement he finds there. The group led a service of remembrance when one of its members who suffered chronic disease died in January.
“He was the same age as me and so close to me,” Miner said. “It can be hard to see God in the midst of tragedy. It was one of the worst of times. But for our group, it was one of the best times spiritually. We really bonded.”
Heath Kirkwood, a first-year seminary student from Brenham, Texas, makes a four-hour round trip on Mondays so he can be with his group.
“I’ve only missed one – the day my baby girl was born,” he said. “I sent an email and send, ‘Guys, I’m not going to be there.’"
While the seminary tries to match compatible students by using questionnaires, “we don’t have a 100 percent rate of satisfaction,” Reed said. “Some people they get along with; some they don’t get along with as well, just like they would in a church staff. This is a training ground, and sometimes that means learning to grow alongside someone you wouldn’t choose as your best friend.”
The Rev. Chris Johnson of Waco’s Chalk Bluff Baptist Church, a 2009 Truett graduate, said that the tools and support he gained in his covenant group have been invaluable in his ministry to about 150 congregants, and he is helping them to form covenant groups as well.
“It’s easy in the classroom for things to be academic, but this is an opportunity to recognize the spiritual nature and to spend time in silence,” he said. “That’s important to students, because many don’t find it elsewhere.
“I’m still in contact with some of the guys in the group,” he said. “They help me to re-energize . . . For me to be effective in the ministry, I have to take care of myself spiritually. I have to get strength from God or I will fail.”
ABOUT BAYLOR UNIVERSITY
Baylor University is a private Christian university and a nationally ranked research institution, characterized as having “high research activity” by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. The university provides a vibrant campus community for approximately 15,000 students by blending interdisciplinary research with an international reputation for educational excellence and a faculty commitment to teaching and scholarship. Chartered in 1845 by the Republic of Texas through the efforts of Baptist pioneers, Baylor is the oldest continually operating university in Texas. Located in Waco, Baylor welcomes students from all 50 states and more than 80 countries to study a broad range of degrees among its 11 nationally recognized academic divisions. Baylor sponsors 19 varsity athletic teams and is a founding member of the Big 12 Conference.
ABOUT GEORGE W. TRUETT THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY
Baylor University’s George W. Truett Theological Seminary provides theological education leading to the Master of Divinity, the Doctor of Ministry or the Master of Theological Studies degree that is centered in the gospel of Jesus Christ and consistent with historic Baptist commitments to prepare persons to carry this gospel to the churches and the world. Within the M.Div. degree program, students can choose concentrations in Biblical Studies and Theology, Christian Education, Ministry Leadership, Missions and World Christianity, Worship Leadership and Youth/Family/Student Ministry. Truett Seminary also offers two Dual Degree programs - M.Div./MSW and MTS/MSW - through a partnership with Baylor’s School of Social Work and an M.Div./Master of Music through a partnership with the Baylor University School of Music. Visit www.baylor.edu/truett to learn more.