Johns Hopkins University Carey Business School

Anticipation, Preparation, Resilience – Key Lessons from COVID-19 for Organizations

Newswise — Johns Hopkins Carey Business School Professor Kathleen Sutcliffe, a leading expert in organization theory, gives low marks to public and private entities for how they’ve responded to the coronavirus threat and outbreak.

A member of the first group of Bloomberg Distinguished Professors appointed by Johns Hopkins University in 2014, Kathleen Sutcliffe has built her career on an examination of the ways organizations behave, especially when facing the unexpected.

Relatively few people anticipated the COVID-19 novel coronavirus outbreak that has unleashed bull markets around the world and driven millions of people indoors on urgent recommendations of “social distancing.”

Talk about your great unexpectations.

Sutcliffe, who has appointments at the Johns Hopkins University Carey Business Schooll, School of Medicine, and School of Nursing, says the current crisis might not have been prevented outright but would have been better contained if public and private organizations had made a routine practice of the approaches she has highlighted in her research – namely, always anticipating and preparing for a crisis, and then reacting to it with intelligence and resilience.

QUESTION: In your recently published book from Oxford University Press – Still Not Safe: Patient Safety and the Middle-Managing of American Medicine (co-authored with Robert Wears) – you noted the continuing prevalence of medical mishaps in the health care system.

How concerned are you that the COVID-19 outbreak will stress the system beyond its capacity?

KATHLEEN SUTCLIFFE: Certainly COVID-19 is going to tax health care systems in unexpected ways. Performance and production pressures increase the possibility that health care professionals are going to miss things in their everyday caregiving situations. If there are added burdens on people because they don’t have resources such as personal protective equipment, have to work overtime, and generally are stressed out and exhausted, that could have unintended consequences on the care that is given and possibly increase the number of medical mishaps.

However, I do want to say that, as studies have shown, nurses, especially on the front lines, are incredibly resilient. Sometimes that resilience is good because it enables them to improvise and catch errors in the making. But sometimes it can be a negative thing because it means that the organization will not get the information it needs about the types of resources that are lacking and how people’s work is affected by pressure situations. In that way, the organization never learns.

People providing health care don’t intend to mess up. But when they’re in the course of doing work, particularly during such a stressful period as this, they might overlook a lot of small signals that are relevant to a patient’s care.

What are the most important lessons that health care systems around the world might take away from this crisis?

Not just health care systems, but all kinds of significant organizations, need to operate through a mindset of anticipation and prevention, and of resilience. Efficiency isn’t the only virtue, especially the kind of efficiency that means cost-cutting. You also need resources devoted to anticipating and preventing crises. Those lean models serve companies and shareholders well, but you also need to think about the people you’re trying to serve. You can’t always be as lean as you want.  You need some redundancy and reserve capacity.

For example, after the 1993 terror attack on the World Trade Center in New York, the New York Board of Trade invested a lot of money in a back-up facility in Queens, away from their usual location at the World Trade Center. They got a lot of flak for that because of the high cost. Critics said, “Why are they spending money on a backup facility that isn’t being used and doesn’t help in their daily operations?” The critics saw it as a redundancy. In fact, not long after the 9/11 attacks, the exchange was up and running, thanks to that preparation, while other financial entities in the city were still on their knees.

As an organization expert, would you offer an opinion of how our leading organizations – in both the public and private sectors – have handled the COVID-19 outbreak?

They don’t get high marks from me, at least so far. Something that drastically harmed our capacity to anticipate and prevent a lot of the damage from the COVID-19 outbreak in the United States was the administration’s disbanding in 2018 of the global health security unit of the National Security Council. That unit was created expressly for crises such as this. We’ve also seen cuts in CDC funding, as well as the departure of many CDC scientists.

And looking at the private sector, it’s equally concerning pharmaceutical companies, to cite one example, have left their supply chains so thin. The public relies on these companies, but they haven’t had enough foresight to consider and anticipate that things can go wrong. Sometimes very wrong.

We won’t really know how we’ve handled this crisis until the dust has settled. What I can say is that we weren’t prepared as well as we could have been, and that’s a concern, because I believe strongly that organizations should always be operating with anticipation, prevention, and resilience as guiding principles.

When we’re through this, there needs to be a serious in-depth study of where we were weak and what we could have done better.

A lot of companies talk about how they prepare for crises, and how they have crisis managers and crisis management teams. But how much actual preparation do they do?

The general concept of crisis management is that crisis is an event; it’s something that came from out of nowhere; it happens, and then you recover from it. So any preparation is about getting back to normal after the fact. But crises usually don’t come from out of the blue, including COVID-19. We’ve known for years that coronaviruses exist, and that there are going to be pandemics. The reaction we’ve seen in most of the world certainly doesn’t indicate we were anticipating it to any degree.

Look, all organizations are going to be surprised. It’s inevitable. But we can design systems to be more anticipatory, so that we catch problems earlier, and to be more resilient, so that we cope more easily and decisively with the situation. If we can think about crisis not as an event but as a process, then we’ll be able to develop ways to see it coming and then mitigate it more promptly.  

Using the sport of expedition racing as a backdrop, you’ve done research showing that organizations encountering crisis benefit from “resilience-in-action.” This includes the positive processes of “drift management” (carefully noting and adjusting to changing circumstances) and “meaning management” (being able to see a way through adversity to a brighter future).

How might these approaches benefit organizations in the midst of COVID-19?

These ideas are basically about intelligent reaction and improvisation. We have to keep attuned to what’s going on and make adjustments as we go along. Don’t panic, we’ll figure this out. Balance realism with optimism.

It’s also critical to avoid the blame game. My research shows that entities do worse when they get into a blame game, compared to entities that avoid blaming and share in all aspects of an experience, the good along with the bad. Blaming takes energy and focus away from the main mission – that mission being how we’re going to work together to figure out realistic solutions to the problem in front of us.




Filters close

Showing results

110 of 3817
Released: 30-Oct-2020 6:35 PM EDT
UCLA Health infectious disease experts tout critical role mask wearing plays in limiting spread of COVID-19
University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Health Sciences

With thousands of new cases logged daily and a vaccine to fight COVID-19 still in development, UCLA Health infectious disease experts are encouraging people to continue to wear masks as the best method of protecting against virus transmission.

Released: 30-Oct-2020 5:35 PM EDT
Surgeon General expects COVID-19 vaccine to be available by year’s end
University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Health Sciences

In a wide-ranging talk with UCLA Health physicians, Wednesday, Oct. 28, United States Surgeon General Jerome Adams, MD, MPH, addressed the politicization of the pandemic and the means of containing the spread of COVID-19. He also offered hope that a vaccine for the virus will be available by year’s end.

Released: 30-Oct-2020 4:15 PM EDT
Study shows myocarditis linked to COVID-19 not as common as believed
Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center - New Orleans

A study conducted by Richard Vander Heide, MD, PhD, Professor and Director of Pathology Research at LSU Health New Orleans School of Medicine, and Marc Halushka, MD, PhD, Professor of Pathology at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, suggests myocarditis caused by COVID-19 may be a relatively rare occurrence.

access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 3-Nov-2020 11:00 AM EST Released to reporters: 30-Oct-2020 3:00 PM EDT

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 3-Nov-2020 11:00 AM EST The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Newswise: 247373_web.jpg
Released: 30-Oct-2020 2:30 PM EDT
Researcher develops app to reach Black community with COVID-19 information
University of Cincinnati

A University of Cincinnati cardiologist is partnering with researchers in St. Louis and rural Georgia to develop a smartphone app that will deliver COVID-19 information and education that is targeted toward Black communities.

Newswise: 247467_web.jpg
Released: 30-Oct-2020 1:55 PM EDT
SARS-CoV-2 might attack red marrow and block new erythrocytes formation
Far Eastern Federal University

Specialists from the Department of Fundamental Medicine of Far Eastern Federal University (FEFU) with Russian and Japanese colleagues have probed into mechanisms of COVID-19 inside-the-body distribution linked to erythrocytes damaging. According to researchers, the virus might attack red marrow, thus being detrimental not only for erythrocytes in the bloodstream but also for the process of the formation of the new ones.

Released: 30-Oct-2020 12:40 PM EDT
Government of Canada awards $2.5M to McMaster University to support the COVID-19 border study with McMaster HealthLabs
McMaster University

McMaster University has been awarded $2.5 million from the Government of Canada to support the McMaster HealthLabs (MHL) Canadian International COVID-19 Surveillance Border Study at Toronto Pearson International Airport, being run in partnership with Air Canada and the Greater Toronto Airports Authority (GTAA).

Released: 30-Oct-2020 12:00 PM EDT
5 Big Questions on Health Care and COVID-19
University of Virginia Darden School of Business

The coronavirus pandemic has once again thrust the unusual state of American health care into the spotlight. With a presidential election that could have a dramatic impact on the state of health care for millions on 3 November, Professor Vivian Riefberg considers the state of the industry.

Newswise: Infection by Confection: COVID-19 and the Risk of Trick-or-Treating
Released: 30-Oct-2020 11:05 AM EDT
Infection by Confection: COVID-19 and the Risk of Trick-or-Treating
University of California San Diego Health

Researchers determined that COVID-19 transmission risk via Halloween candies is low, even when they are handled by infected people, but handwashing and disinfecting collected sweets reduces risk even further.

Newswise:Video Embedded third-spike-in-covid-19-cases-plus-the-vaccine-trials-live-expert-panel-for-october-29-3pm-edt
VIDEO
Released: 30-Oct-2020 9:40 AM EDT
TRANSCRIPT AND VIDEO AVAILABLE: "Third spike" in COVID-19 cases, plus the vaccine trials: Live Expert Panel for October 29
Newswise

"Third spike" in COVID-19 cases, plus the vaccine trials: Live Expert Panel for October 29, 3PM EDT


Showing results

110 of 3817

close
1.10943