Expert Pitch
University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV)

COVID-19 and the Ethical Questions it Poses

22-Apr-2020 11:05 AM EDT, by University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV)

The coronavirus pandemic has been unprecedented in its impact, leaving no aspect of life unaffected from its arrival in late 2019.

From day-to-day impacts on work, school, social gatherings, and travel, to larger shockwaves to the world’s economy and health care systems, COVID-19 is a once-in-a-lifetime crisis on the global stage.

And with such a large crisis comes even larger, albeit, difficult questions to answer. Questions that tug at the ethical dilemmas the crisis has brought to the forefront.

For health care workers caring for sick coronavirus patients: How do we allocate scarce resources?

For government leaders pushing for a vaccine: Who gets the first shot when one becomes available?

For businesses who are facing falling revenues: Will shareholders continue to be their No. 1 focus, post-COVID-19?

These are just a few of the many ethical challenges the world needs to wrestle with now and in the near future, according to Wonyong Oh, Lee Professor of Strategy at UNLV’s Lee Business School.

We sat down – virtually – with Oh, to talk about these and other questions that the world’s population is now facing, and where we go from here.

Last month, the hospital system in Italy was overwhelmed with coronavirus cases. As the country begins to turn a positive corner, what are some lessons to be learned from Italy on how to handle questions of medical ethics?

In countries such as Italy, China, the United Kingdom, and Spain, frontline medical staffs have faced a dilemma throughout the COVID-19 crisis: Which patients should be treated first when resources are stretched to the limit? Should you save as many patients as possible, or save patients with the most urgent need?

From an ethical standpoint, if you believe in the ethics of outcome (utilitarianism), or aim to save the largest number of lives, you should focus on patients who have greater chances of therapeutic success. In contrast, if you believe in the ethics of morality (deontology), you should treat patients who are at risk, like elderly patients who are in serious conditions.

It’s likely that no one can answer this question. The important lesson is that we shouldn't just leave this decision to the frontline health workers. Guidelines can be provided to ease their moral burden, so that they can better focus on treatment. For example, both Italy and the United Kingdom offer guidelines for their health care professionals.

Scientists around the world are working quickly to develop vaccines for COVID-19. When they are successful, and a vaccine becomes available, who should get the first shot? 

We’ve seen this question in the movie “Contagion”, but it could actually be a question we have to answer in a few months. This question poses an ethical question similar to questions of who will be treated first. Will the vaccine first go to more vulnerable people or people with high social utility (e.g., medical professionals)? Vaccine development is important, but, once vaccines are available, the distribution of a vaccine is also an important ethical question.

Think about how the masks, gloves and diagnostic kits are distributed these days. Simply, the distribution is determined by who pays the highest amount. This shows that the supply and demand curve cannot solve the distribution problem. If vaccines are also distributed in a similar way, poorer countries will unfortunately get the vaccines last.  

Some richer countries are likely to preempt and stock up on vaccines for the protection of their own citizens. They’re able to do so because there is no regulatory force that mandates countries that develop vaccines to share those vaccines with other countries. That's why Bill Gates argued recently for a worldwide approach to fighting the disease, and that the vaccine should be a “global public good”.

What are some ethical questions that businesses are wrestling with in light of COVID-19?

Let’s think about one controversial example. Real-time personal location information to track and manage the path of infection has been tried all over the world, especially actively in Asian countries like China, Korea, and Hong Kong. IT companies can track location information using smartphones to prevent virus spread. This raises ethical and legal issues surrounding access to personal information.

If you follow utilitarian ethics, tracking this kind of personal information can be allowed with the “maximum benefits for the greatest number” principle. It’s for keeping society safe from infection by sacrificing personal privacy. It seems that, recently, the views on tracking personal information in the U.S. and Europe began to change. In a few European countries, telecommunication companies began to use mobile phone data to fight COVID-19. In the U.S., Apple and Google are working together to track COVID-19 with Bluetooth. IT companies can help governments reduce the spread of the virus with their technologies. At the same time, high-tech companies need to balance that with protecting individual privacy, which is a new challenge.

Everything about the coronavirus pandemic, however, is unprecedented. The reality is that the virus threatens even ordinary freedoms, like the freedom of movement, with stay-at-home orders.

Will the pandemic make some businesses rethink the fundamental aspect of corporation?

Let’s talk about one concept — efficiency. For decades, U.S. corporations and business schools have emphasized the importance of efficiency. Think about Germany. COVID-19 has hit the country hard, but the fatality rate is remarkably low at around 1.6 percent as I write this. By comparison, that rate is 12 percent in Italy and about 10 percent in Spain, France, and the U.K.

One of the reasons is that Germany has more hospital doctors, hospital beds, and intensive care units than other comparable European countries. For example, Germany has 34 intensive care beds – equipped with ventilators – per 100,000 people, whereas it’s only 12 in Italy. Based on the traditional business paradigm before this pandemic, that’s a sign of inefficiency, or failure to make the best use of resources. But now, no one will argue that Italy has better ‘health care efficiency’ than Germany.   

After this pandemic, how will the roles of corporation and government change? Do you expect more corporate social responsibility? 

U.S. business schools have taught the shareholder primacy model, which emphasizes the maximization of shareholder value. But this will change.

We are already seeing some examples. Facebook and Micron are giving $1,000 to each of their employees to support them during the COVID-19 outbreak. Also, car insurance companies are offering customers refunds and credits. Apparel companies began producing protective gear. Microsoft is collaborating with Johns Hopkins’ coronavirus tracker. They don’t have to, but they did. If they didn’t, it would financially profit Microsoft shareholders only. These companies recognize the importance of treating employees, customers, and society responsibly. We may see more companies shifting their mindsets from ‘shareholder capitalism’ to ‘stakeholder capitalism.’

However, we cannot completely rely on a few good corporate citizens. Over the past few decades, vaccine development by pharmaceutical companies has decreased dramatically. Pharmaceutical companies have also reduced their investment in making new ones. This is in part because research, development, and testing are costly and involve high risk of failure. Also, the market for vaccines is smaller compared to other drugs, and there is no market once the pandemic is over. To put it simply, it’s not a profitable endeavor for pharmaceutical companies, and thus they have no financial incentive to develop vaccines. How can we deal with this problem? Since market capitalism cannot solve it, governments need to step in.

Filters close

Showing results

110 of 2527
Released: 10-Jul-2020 12:50 PM EDT
Genetic ‘fingerprints’ of first COVID-19 cases help manage pandemic
University of Sydney

A new study published in the world-leading journal Nature Medicine, reveals how genomic sequencing and mathematical modelling gave important insights into the ‘parentage’ of cases and likely spread of the disease in New South Wales.

Released: 10-Jul-2020 12:35 PM EDT
Our itch to share helps spread COVID-19 misinformation
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

To stay current about the Covid-19 pandemic, people need to process health information when they read the news. Inevitably, that means people will be exposed to health misinformation, too, in the form of false content, often found online, about the illness.

Newswise: Pandemic Inspires Framework for Enhanced Care in Nursing Homes
Released: 10-Jul-2020 12:25 PM EDT
Pandemic Inspires Framework for Enhanced Care in Nursing Homes
University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing

As of May 2020, nursing home residents account for a staggering one-third of the more than 80,000 deaths due to COVID-19 in the U.S. This pandemic has resulted in unprecedented threats—like reduced access to resources needed to contain and eliminate the spread of the virus—to achieving and sustaining care quality even in the best nursing homes. Active engagement of nursing home leaders in developing solutions responsive to the unprecedented threats to quality standards of care delivery is required.

Newswise: General Electric Healthcare Chooses UH to Clinically 
Evaluate First-of-its-kind Imaging System
Released: 10-Jul-2020 12:15 PM EDT
General Electric Healthcare Chooses UH to Clinically Evaluate First-of-its-kind Imaging System
University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center

University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center physicians completed evaluation for the GE Healthcare Critical Care Suite, and the technology is now in daily clinical practice – flagging between seven to 15 collapsed lungs per day within the hospital. No one on the team could have predicted the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, but this technology and future research with GEHC may enhance the capability to improve care for COVID-19 patients in the ICU. Critical Care Suite is now assisting in COVID and non-COVID patient care as the AMX 240 travels to intensive care units within the hospital.

Released: 10-Jul-2020 11:50 AM EDT
COVID-19 Can Be Transmitted in the Womb, Reports Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal
Wolters Kluwer Health: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins

A baby girl in Texas – born prematurely to a mother with COVID-19 – is the strongest evidence to date that intrauterine (in the womb) transmission of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) can occur, reports The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal, the official journal of The European Society for Paediatric Infectious Diseases. The journal is published in the Lippincott portfolio by Wolters Kluwer.

Released: 10-Jul-2020 9:45 AM EDT
How COVID-19 Shifted Inpatient Imaging Utilization
Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute

As medical resources shifted away from elective and non-urgent procedures toward emergent and critical care of COVID-19 patients, departments were forced to reconfigure their personnel and resources. In particular, many Radiology practices rescheduled non-urgent and routine imaging according to recommendations from the American College of Radiology (ACR). This new Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute study, published online in the Journal of American College of Radiology (JACR), evaluates the change in the inpatient imaging volumes and composition mix during the COVID-19 pandemic within a large healthcare system.

access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 12-Jul-2020 7:00 PM EDT Released to reporters: 10-Jul-2020 9:00 AM EDT

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 12-Jul-2020 7:00 PM EDT The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Released: 10-Jul-2020 9:00 AM EDT
Team is first in Texas to investigate convalescent plasma for prevention of COVID-19 onset and progression
University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston

A research team is the first in Texas to investigate whether plasma from COVID-19 survivors can be used in outpatient settings to prevent the onset and progression of the virus in two new clinical trials at UTHealth.

Showing results

110 of 2527