University of Cambridge

Healthcare rationing could see ‘unlawful deaths' from COVID-19, researchers claim

21-May-2020 7:45 AM EDT, by University of Cambridge

Newswise — While the initial coronavirus peak is starting to pass – in Europe, at least – without the ventilator shortages many feared, the spectre of a second wave or future outbreak means questions of medical rationing still hold sway.

New research suggests that current ICU protocols and ethical guidelines lack detail, and leave doctors exposed to legal liability if another contagion surge forces them to make painful snap decisions due to insufficient resources.

While the latest analysis focuses on ventilators, University of Cambridge researchers say that many of their arguments apply to other potential medical shortages e.g. a lack of properly staffed ICU beds, dialysis machines or related supplies or equipment.

If shortages lead to denial of treatment based on disability – including ‘chronic illness’ – or age, or treatment withdrawal during sedation, it could violate patient rights and cause unlawful death, argue the Cambridge lawyers.   

They say that legal liability could extend to the UK Government if it is required to defend failures to purchase more medical supplies or publish ICU rationing guidance, despite knowledge of risks to life posed by the pandemic.

The study, published in the Journal of Medical Ethics, is based on UK law, but researchers say it is relevant to other European nations.

“We’re definitely not out of the woods,” said Dr Kathy Liddell, Director of the Cambridge Centre for Law, Medicine and Life Sciences. “With lockdown easing, we might well see a second Covid-19 spike in intensive care units, and health services should be prepared legally as well as medically.”

“The law requires more of hospitals, doctors and clinical commissioning groups than is currently set out in the guidelines provided by the British Medical Association, the Intensive Care Society and medical ethicists.”

“The legal rights of patients matter, and they are not being given the attention they deserve,” she said.

Around 2.5% of Covid-19 patients require mechanical ventilation to live while they fight the virus, and a patient can need assisted breathing for up to three weeks.

Early concerns that the virus would see patient demand overwhelm ventilator supply prompted researchers to investigate the legal limits of ventilator allocation.

They found “little concrete guidance” centrally in the UK, and argue that a shortage could see “postcode lotteries” of patient rights to life saving treatment – as decisions are taken at a local level by hospitals and doctors.

“The guidelines we reviewed differed in many ways,” said co-author Dr Jeff Skopek, from Cambridge’s Faculty of Law. “But they generally had the same goal:  save as many lives as possible. While this is of course a worthy goal, it can lead to the violation of patients’ rights – rights are not suspended merely because we are in a crisis.”

The researchers argue that a ventilator cannot be denied on the grounds that a patient has a disability. “Denying treatment because of a disability, which includes chronic illness, violates the Equalities Act 2010. Denying treatment based on age may also do so,” said Liddell.

“In fact, the Equalities Act requires efforts be taken not to disadvantage disabled people. This may mean giving people with disabilities longer assessment periods on ventilation, or actually not de-prioritising them,” she said.

The analysis points out that if an initial trial of treatment is proposed, it must not be too short. No one should be taken off a ventilator for reallocation purposes until the trial has been long enough to generate reliable evidence for predicting the patient’s outcome.

Any decision to withhold or remove ventilation must involve consultation with the patient or their family. Moreover, withdrawing a ventilator without bringing the patient out of sedation risks unlawful killing.

“Even though returning to consciousness would be deeply distressing, all patients must be given a chance to breathe independently if they have a meaningful chance of surviving until another ventilator is available,” said Liddell.

If some of these scenarios occur during another virus spike, the researchers say doctors could be directly liable under criminal law for charges such as gross negligence manslaughter, criminal battery or willful neglect.

Even the UK Government could be held responsible. As Skopek highlights, the decision taken by government in April 2020 not to provide a national policy on handling ICU shortages – despite recommendations from its Moral and Ethical Advisory group – could result in a violation of its obligations under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

“Without a national policy, the task of drawing up ICU rationing guidelines was left to individual CCGs and hospitals, and many lacked support to ensure their guidelines were legal and ethically sound,” he said.  

Added Skopek: “If we end up with another surge in patients that overwhelms our critical care infrastructure, hospitals and doctors may end up acting unlawfully – and worse, patients may end up dying unlawfully.”

SEE ORIGINAL STUDY




Filters close

Showing results

110 of 4190
access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 8-Dec-2020 11:00 AM EST Released to reporters: 3-Dec-2020 8:30 AM EST

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 8-Dec-2020 11:00 AM EST The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Newswise: The Medical Minute: Helping young athletes return to play safely after COVID-19
Released: 3-Dec-2020 8:20 AM EST
The Medical Minute: Helping young athletes return to play safely after COVID-19
Penn State Health

Young athletes in central Pennsylvania can’t wait to start basketball and wrestling season. But with the COVID-19 pandemic raging, parents wonder how their children can stay safe. And, if their child gets COVID-19, parents wonder when it’s safe for that child to get back to competitive sports.

Released: 2-Dec-2020 6:05 PM EST
How Caregivers of People with Dementia Can Navigate Holidays During the Pandemic
Rutgers University-New Brunswick

As COVID-19 cases increase across the nation, many caregivers are trying to navigate the holidays for relatives with dementia or Alzheimer’s disease. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention suggests that people not travel to limit the potential spread of the coronavirus. Mary Catherine Lundquist, program director of Care2Caregivers, a peer counseling helpline (800-424-2494) for caregivers of people with dementia and Alzheimer’s disease operated by Rutgers Behavioral Health Care, discusses how families can stay connected with their loved ones.

Released: 2-Dec-2020 3:50 PM EST
Tip Sheet: Celebrate holidays safely, COVID-19 vaccines, challenges in HIV vaccine trials — and new insights on evolution
Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center

SEATTLE – Dec. 2, 2020 – Below are summaries of recent Fred Hutch research findings and other news with links for additional background and media contacts.If you’re following the American Society of Hematology’s annual meeting (virtual, Dec. 5-8), see our media tip sheet highlighting Fred Hutch presentations and activities, including those by current ASH president Dr.

Newswise: “This is how we can help” – Couple shares their story as COVID-19 clinical trial participants
Released: 2-Dec-2020 2:35 PM EST
“This is how we can help” – Couple shares their story as COVID-19 clinical trial participants
University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston

“I don’t feel so great,” my husband, Brandon, said to me one Saturday afternoon – the last thing I wanted to hear after spending the last seven months tuned into COVID-19 media coverage. Knowing a few of his co-workers had recently tested positive for the virus, we didn’t wait to secure an appointment for a rapid test. When he called me an hour later to tell me he has tested positive, my heart sank.

Released: 2-Dec-2020 2:35 PM EST
IPC Statement On SARS-CoV-2 Vaccines And Psoriasis
International Psoriasis Council

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic continues to have a considerable impact on the provision of appropriate care to people with psoriasis.

Newswise: 250245_web.jpg
Released: 2-Dec-2020 2:05 PM EST
Differences in immunity and blood vessels likely protect children from severe COVID-19
Murdoch Childrens Research Institute

Differences in the immune systems and better blood vessel health were among the factors protecting children from severe COVID-19, according to a new review.

Newswise: Telemedicine Use During COVID-19 Shows Access Disparity Among Head and Neck Cancer Patients
Released: 2-Dec-2020 1:30 PM EST
Telemedicine Use During COVID-19 Shows Access Disparity Among Head and Neck Cancer Patients
Henry Ford Health System

Retrospective research by Henry Ford otolaryngologists found telemedicine use disparity among head and neck cancer patients during start of COVID-19 pandemic.

Released: 2-Dec-2020 1:15 PM EST
Researchers determine how the SARS-CoV-2 virus hijacks and rapidly causes damage to human lung cells
Boston University School of Medicine

In a multi-group collaborative involving the National Emerging Infectious Disease Laboratories (NEIDL), the Center for Regenerative Medicine (CReM), and the Center for Network Systems Biology (CNSB), scientists have reported the first map of the molecular responses of human lung cells to infection by SARS-CoV-2.


Showing results

110 of 4190

close
1.75079