Pediatric scoring scale helps surgeons decide whether to operate during COVID-19 delays

As understanding grows about how COVID-19 impacts children, surgeons present findings on a new pediatric specific-tool to prioritize operations in a new Journal of the American College of Surgeons article
27-May-2020 3:40 PM EDT, by American College of Surgeons (ACS)

Newswise — CHICAGO (May 27, 2020): As health care providers observe Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) affecting children differently than adults, pediatric surgeons in Chicago have modified an evaluation tool for use in pediatric patients that allows surgeons in every pediatric specialty to prioritize nonemergency (“elective”) operations during all phases of the pandemic. The new pediatric-specific scoring system is presented in an “article in press” on the Journal of the American College of Surgeons (JACS) website ahead of print.

Called the Pediatric Medically Necessary Time-Sensitive, or pMeNTS, scoring system, the new index score created by researchers at The University of Chicago (UChicago) Medicine adapts the adult MeNTS approach. That original surgical prioritization approach was published on April 9 in a scientific article on the JACS website amid COVID-19-related resource constraints and nationwide recommendations to postpone elective operations.1

Pediatric surgeons at UChicago Medicine found that the adult MeNTS scoring system needed revisions for optimal use in pediatric surgery, according to Mark B. Slidell, MD, MPH, FACS, the lead investigator and associate professor of surgery at UChicago Medicine.

“It was very important to create a pediatric-specific system that recognizes there are big differences between adults and children,” Dr. Slidell said.

Need for revised scoring system

Among the differences is that many children testing positive for COVID-19 appear asymptomatic (have no symptoms).2Also, recent reports noted a new serious complication of COVID-19 in some infected children, including those who were unaware they had the virus: an inflammatory syndrome that can lead to severe involvement of multiple organs.2

Dr. Slidell’s coauthor, Grace Z. Mak, MD, FACS, UChicago Medicine associate professor of pediatrics and surgery, said users of the pMeNTS scoring worksheet can adapt it to include new COVID-19 developments.

“Part of what we took into account is that asymptomatic COVID-positive patients in the pediatric population could very well have a worse outcome, and multisystem organ failure is a good example,” Dr. Mak said.

As the pandemic changes the concept of elective operations, pMeNTS focuses on an operation’s medical necessity and time-sensitivity—the effect of treatment delay on the patient’s disease. Plus, it assesses COVID-19 factors such as infection risk for the patient and providers as well as projected use of hospital resources, including protective gear, beds, blood products, and staffing. The tool, which Dr. Slidell emphasizes is not a risk calculator, systematically evaluates factors related to the procedure, the patient’s disease, and the patient’s individual risks. Users rate each factor on a five-point scale and total the scores. A lower overall pMeNTS score indicates a more favorable surgical risk, less risk to personnel, and less resource utilization, and can be used to determine a higher priority for the procedure.

The hospital’s surgical department leaders review the assigned scores for each surgical case and can shift the scoring cutoff each day for high-priority operations depending on available resources, Dr. Mak stated.

Unlike the adult scoring system, pMeNTS accounts for chronic diseases of childhood and birth defects such as prematurity or congenital heart and lung diseases that may raise susceptibility to more severe COVID-19 infection. It omits chronic illnesses of adulthood that are rare in children such as coronary artery disease and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

Another key change was pediatric age brackets reflecting the impact of age on a procedure. For instance, Dr. Mak said a hernia repair is a more difficult operation in a premature infant than a 14-year-old patient. In the adult MeNTS system, both patients would have the same score, but pMeNTS accounts for the child’s age and assigns the infant a higher number, she explained.

Testing the system

The investigators tested pMeNTS in 101 pediatric patients scheduled for operations at UChicago Comer Children’s Hospital from March 23 to April 19. In the article, they reported the system to be “a safe, equitable, transparent, and ethical strategy to prioritize children’s surgical procedures.”

During that month, they analyzed a sample of 53 deferred cases and 48 cases that were allowed to proceed as scheduled. Procedures they deemed time-sensitive included cancer biopsies and operations needed for discharge from the intensive care unit (ICU), thus freeing ICU beds, Dr. Mak said.

The researchers also compared scores of a sample of 21 patients using both the pediatric and adult scoring systems. Most children, they found, had higher scores with the adult MeNTS. Dr. Slidell said pMeNTS successfully captured the various factors that are unique to children.

Strengths of the pMeNTS tool, according to Dr. Slidell, include the flexibility to adapt to changes in the health care system now and during recovery from the pandemic. Because the tool received input from many different specialists, he said it works well across various pediatric surgical subspecialties.

The transparency of the pMeNTS tool has reduced surgeons’ moral dilemmas in the difficult decision-making process of which sick children can proceed with their scheduled operations, Dr. Slidell noted.

He said, “This is one of the most important questions to ask any time we are scheduling a procedure during a time like this: ‘Am I making the best decision with the information I have for the patient, for the hospital, for the workers in the hospital, and for the community at large?’ ”

Study coauthors are Jessica J. Kandel, MD, FACS; Vivek Prachand, MD, FACS; Fuad M. Baroody, MD; Mohan S. Gundeti, MD; Russell R. Reid, MD; Peter Angelos, MD, FACS; and Jeffrey B. Matthews, MD, FACS, all from the UChicago Medicine Department of Surgery.

The authors report no relevant disclosures related to the scope of this work.

“FACS” designates that a surgeon is a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons. 

Citation: Pediatric modification of the Medically Necessary, Time-Sensitive scoring system for operating room procedure prioritization during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of the American College of Surgeons. DOI:

Prachand VN, Milner R, Angelos P, et al. Medically necessary, time-sensitive procedures: scoring system to ethically and efficiently manage resource scarcity and provider risk during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of the American College of Surgeons. 2020. DOI: https:/

2 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Information for pediatric healthcare providers. Updated May 15, 2020. Accessed May 19, 2020.

# # #

About the American College of Surgeons
The American College of Surgeons is a scientific and educational organization of surgeons that was founded in 1913 to raise the standards of surgical practice and improve the quality of care for surgical patients. The College is dedicated to the ethical and competent practice of surgery. Its achievements have significantly influenced the course of scientific surgery in America and have established it as an important advocate for all surgical patients. The College has more than 82,000 members and is the largest organization of surgeons in the world. For more information, visit


Filters close

Showing results

110 of 2552
14-Jul-2020 8:55 AM EDT
Rapid genome sequencing and screening help hospital manage COVID-19 outbreaks
University of Cambridge

Cambridge researchers have shown how rapid genome sequencing of virus samples and enhanced testing of hospital staff can help to identify clusters of healthcare-associated COVID-19 infections.

Newswise: 236709_web.jpg
Released: 14-Jul-2020 3:05 PM EDT
When a pandemic strikes, we still expect an ambulance
Edith Cowan University

Research published today has found that Australians strongly believe paramedics deserve a work environment free from the threat of physical harm, but when it comes to the risk of infectious disease, it's complicated.

Newswise: Story Tips From Johns Hopkins Experts on COVID-19
Released: 14-Jul-2020 12:40 PM EDT
Story Tips From Johns Hopkins Experts on COVID-19
Johns Hopkins Medicine

Sharon Tapp, who worked as a nurse case manager at Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Washington, D.C., started experiencing sudden body weakness, chest pain, a high temperature and headache on March 18. Concerned, she went to her local urgent care center to find out what was wrong. They told her that these symptoms were flu-like, tested her for the coronavirus and told her to quarantine for 14 days. After five days and no difference in the presentation of her symptoms, the urgent care team contacted Sharon, letting her know that she tested positive for coronavirus and recommending that she go to the emergency department. Sharon’s family took her to Johns Hopkins Medicine’s Suburban Hospital. Because her condition worsened while at Suburban, she was transferred to The Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore within 10 days of being admitted to Suburban Hospital.

Released: 14-Jul-2020 12:05 PM EDT
National Glaucoma Research Foundation Survey Reveals Glaucoma Patients’ Experiences and Concerns During COVID-19 Pandemic
Glaucoma Research Foundation

National survey finds appointment delays and cancellations were the greatest cause of concern; waiting for in-person appointments is greatly preferred over telemedicine.

Newswise: Palliative Nursing’s Role During COVID-19 and Beyond
Released: 14-Jul-2020 11:35 AM EDT
Palliative Nursing’s Role During COVID-19 and Beyond
University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing

As a rapid influx of patients overwhelmed health systems during the coronavirus pandemic, palliative nurses played dual roles supporting patients, patient families, and colleagues. Two researchers at the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing (Penn Nursing) are among those detailing the important role palliative care has in responding during the COVID-19 pandemic and in future public health crises.

Newswise: 237436_web.jpg
Released: 14-Jul-2020 11:20 AM EDT
New study shows SARS-CoV-2 viral load peaks in the early stages of disease

In a retrospective study, investigators from New York University Langone Health found that the quantity of SARS-CoV-2 (viral load) collected from patients in the emergency department is significantly higher in patients with fewer or milder symptoms who did not require hospitalization--the opposite of what might be expected.

Newswise: Hackensack Meridian CDI has Struck a COVID-19 Research Collaboration with Merck
Released: 14-Jul-2020 10:00 AM EDT
Hackensack Meridian CDI has Struck a COVID-19 Research Collaboration with Merck
Hackensack Meridian Health

The CDI will work with Merck to identify candidate treatments for the still-spreading pandemic.

Released: 14-Jul-2020 9:00 AM EDT
COVID-19 pandemic could be learning opportunity for middle-grade students
Binghamton University, State University of New York

Educators could use the COVID-19 outbreak to help middle-schoolers better understand the world, according to new research from faculty at Binghamton University, State University of New York.

Showing results

110 of 2552