Ohio State University

State actions played lesser role in COVID-19 economic damage

Hispanics, younger workers, less educated lost more jobs
11-May-2020 8:15 AM EDT, by Ohio State University

Newswise — COLUMBUS, Ohio – Actions by state governments to try to limit the spread of COVID-19 played only a secondary role in the historic spike in U.S. unemployment in March, according to new research. 

While state actions to close schools were linked to an increase in unemployment, these effects were dwarfed by the larger national and international impact of the pandemic, according to researchers at The Ohio State University and Indiana University. 

Hispanics, young adults (aged 20-24), those without a college education and those with four or more children saw the steepest job losses. 

In two separate studies, the researchers took a broad look at the very early impact of the pandemic on jobs in the United States. 

One study looked at the overall effects of COVID-19 case rates and state actions on early unemployment rates.  The second study looked at which groups were most impacted by job losses early in the pandemic. 

The studies are an attempt to help understand an unprecedented economic event in American history, said Bruce Weinberg, co-author of the studies and professor of economics at Ohio State

“None of the methods, none of the tools we use in economics are built to get at millions of people losing their jobs in just weeks. That’s not what happens in normal times,” Weinberg said. 

“Part of the contribution of our studies is trying to get real-time information from data from surveys and tools that were really designed to understand a more gradual process.” 

Both studies were published May 11, 2020 as National Bureau of Economic Research working papers. 

For the first study, the researchers used data on new unemployment insurance claims during the weeks of March 15-21 and March 22-28 to measure the economic impact.  They used school closures as a measure of each state’s attempt to limit the disease spread.

School closures were one of the earliest responses by states to curb the spread of the virus, which was one key reason it was used in this study, said Xuan Jiang, co-author of the studies and a postdoctoral researcher in economics at Ohio State. 

“Closures may impact the economy by reducing consumer and labor demand and making it harder for parents to remain productive at work because of child care responsibilities,” Jiang said. 

The size of the spike in unemployment claims by March 21, compared to March 14, was highest in states with the most intensive school closures – a 1,704 percent increase.  States in the intermediate group of school closures had a 1,047 percent increase in unemployment claims, while the lowest group had a 593 percent increase. 

“Even the smallest response by the states implies a record-setting 6-fold increase in unemployment insurance claims in only one week,” Jiang said. 

“It is unlikely that states could have avoided the huge spike in job losses by avoiding early school closures.” 

The percentage of people who tested positive for COVID-19 in a state had an even less significant connection to the number of new unemployment claims by March 21.  Findings showed that claims grew 1,281 percent in states with high COVID-19 case rates and 1,095 percent in states with comparatively lower COVID-19 case rates. 

“What our results suggest is that state-level policies and COVID cases aren’t the primary drivers of the economic devastation we’re seeing now,” Weinberg said. 

“The states are really at the mercy of larger forces that are out of their control,” he said, such as reduced consumer activity as awareness and fear of the coronavirus grew. 

The second study used data from the federal government’s monthly Current Population Survey to compare employment in March (after pandemic shutdowns began) with February. 

As expected, findings showed job losses were largest in occupations that required more face-to-face contact (such as service industries) and that cannot be performed remotely.

The demographic group that had the largest decline in employment in March – nearly 4 percentage points – was workers aged 20 to 24.  Those who didn’t have a high school degree were second-hardest hit, followed by Hispanics. Those with four or more children were also hit hard. Black workers were more likely to lose their jobs than white workers. 

The researchers analyzed the data to try to understand why some demographic groups were affected more than others. 

Findings showed that Hispanics and those without a college education suffered higher job losses at least partially because they tended to be employed in service industries and others where they could not work remotely. 

But for many groups – like blacks and younger workers – the data explained very little about why they were more likely to lose their jobs.

“Some of that could be discrimination, which we can’t capture in our data,” Jiang said. “In some cases, the data may just not allow us to observe the reasons why people aren’t working.” 

Overall, the data suggest that most job losses occurred because businesses closed or laid off workers in response to the pandemic, Weinberg said. It wasn’t the case that workers quit because they feared getting sick. 

“Maybe when businesses start back up, we’ll start to see workers who are reluctant to take jobs where they might be at risk of exposure to the virus,” he said.  

While these two studies focused on the beginning of the pandemic in the United States, the findings may be relevant to governors as they weigh decisions to “reopen” their states to business, Weinberg said. 

“We found state decisions had limited impact on their economies, at least at the beginning of this crisis,” Weinberg said. 

Decisions to reopen businesses may also not provide a big economic boost at first.

“Even without state mandates, people may decide to avoid or severely reduce going to restaurants, shopping in stores or taking trips. Consumer demand may not return right away,” he said. 

Jiang added: “That’s a reason to doubt the effectiveness of reopening businesses in the short term. There may not be a lot that individual states can do for their economies in the short term.” 

Other co-authors on both studies, all from Indiana University, were Felipe Lozano Rojas and Laura Montenovo, doctoral students; Kosali Simon, professor of health economics; and Coady Wing, associate professor of public and environmental affairs. Ian Schmutte of the University of Georgia was a co-author on the second paper.





Filters close

Showing results

1120 of 2484
Released: 7-Jul-2020 12:50 PM EDT
Remdesivir can save more lives where ICUs are overwhelmed
Boston University School of Medicine

Amid news that the United States has bought up virtually the entire global supply of remdesivir, a new Boston University School of Public Health (BUSPH) study outlines how the drug could save lives in countries with less hospital capacity, such as South Africa, where COVID-19 is beginning to overwhelm intensive care units (ICUs).

Newswise: Cedars-Sinai Named Age-Friendly Health System
Released: 7-Jul-2020 12:40 PM EDT
Cedars-Sinai Named Age-Friendly Health System

Shortly after COVID-19 was declared a pandemic, more than 450 older adults learned their weekly exercise classes offered through the Cedars-Sinai Geriatrics Program were on hold. But under the quick-thinking direction of geriatrician Allison Moser Mays, MD, the program pivoted, creating a way for seniors to access live classes over Zoom from the comfort of their homes. The online format has proved especially popular.

Newswise: WashU Expert: Eviction moratoriums are incomplete solution
Released: 7-Jul-2020 11:55 AM EDT
WashU Expert: Eviction moratoriums are incomplete solution
Washington University in St. Louis

Millions of tenants are at risk of eviction as protections in the CARES Act are set to expire. While the U.S. Congress and Senate are proposing plans to extend the federal moratorium on evictions, a finance expert at Washington University in St. Louis warns that is just one piece of the puzzle.

Released: 7-Jul-2020 11:40 AM EDT
Beaumont researchers develop COVID-19 test that can detect virus in saliva, blood or urine in 45 minutes
Beaumont Health

Rapid test for COVID-19 can help contain the virus and contribute to a successful reopening of the economy

Released: 7-Jul-2020 11:15 AM EDT
Study: surgical delay associated with increased risk in some gastrointestinal malignancies
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, widespread cancellations of electively-scheduled or “non-emergency” operations were implemented to free up hospital beds and conserve protective equipment for health care workers. For some conditions, including cancer, timely surgery is critical for patients’ survival. In a new study published in the Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, a team of investigators at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) examined the effects of delaying surgery for gastrointestinal cancers.

Newswise: GettyImages%20Sickle%20Cell.jpg
Released: 7-Jul-2020 9:35 AM EDT
COVID-19: What you should know if you have sickle cell disease
LifeBridge Health

If you have sickle cell disease, you are at higher risk than the general population for severe complications from COVID-19.

Newswise: sharon-mccutcheon-8lnbXtxFGZw-unsplash-1024x683.jpg
Released: 6-Jul-2020 4:50 PM EDT
COVID-19 demonstrates why wealth matters
Washington University in St. Louis

While COVID-19 has impacted all individuals, the impact has not been equal. In a new national Socioeconomic Impact of COVID-19 survey, the Social Policy Institute at Washington University in St. Louis found that liquid assets increased the likelihood that an individual could practice social distancing. However, Black individuals were least likely to afford social distancing.

Newswise: University of Miami Launches COVID-19 Heart Program
Released: 6-Jul-2020 2:50 PM EDT
University of Miami Launches COVID-19 Heart Program
University of Miami Health System, Miller School of Medicine

A new COVID-19 Heart Program developed by cardiologists with the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine is addressing the varied heart issues stemming from the pandemic with comprehensive screenings and evaluations in a safe clinical setting. It also incorporates the latest findings from UM cardiology researchers studying how the coronavirus can affect the heart and its surrounding tissues.

Released: 6-Jul-2020 1:40 PM EDT
US hydroxychloroquine, chloroquine, azithromycin outpatient prescriptions October 2019-March 2020
JAMA - Journal of the American Medical Association

What The Study Did: How the prescription of hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine to outpatients has changed in the United States during the COVID-19 pandemic is examined in this study.

Newswise: What Is the World Doing to Create a COVID-19 Vaccine?
Released: 6-Jul-2020 1:10 PM EDT
What Is the World Doing to Create a COVID-19 Vaccine?
Council on Foreign Relations (CFR)

The race to find a vaccine for the new coronavirus is well underway. Governments and researchers are aiming to provide billions of people with immunity in eighteen months or less, which would be unprecedented.

Showing results

1120 of 2484