- 2020-12-09 17:35:46
- Article ID: 743094
Managing Ecosystem Restoration: What Does Success Look Like?
Systems ecology-based methods to advance effective large-scale restoration
-
Credit: Photo by Paul Stodola | U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Interconnected networks of wetland restoration projects benefit many species, such as these wetland wading birds in the Florida Everglades.
-
Credit: Photo by Paul Stodola | U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
In the Florida Everglades, improved stormwater management since the 1990s has facilitated restoration efforts for wetland habitat, benefitting species such as alligators (adult and juvenile pictured).
-
Credit: Illustration by Nathan Johnson and Heida Diefenderfer | Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
To aid future restoration planning, the research team evaluated some of the country’s major restoration programs in recent decades and defined eight major effects to consider in future planning
By Kelsey Adkisson
As projects grow in size and complexity, so do the restoration costs. This underscores the need for a strategic approach to maximize both ecological and economic benefits.
A national team of researchers, led by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), evaluated large-scale restoration efforts across the country and developed criteria, techniques, and tools to determine outcomes and ultimately, maximize benefits. This work was the focus of a study published in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment.
Measuring the outcomes of expensive ecosystem restoration efforts
Anyone flying over San Francisco Bay will see a colorful kaleidoscope of large ponds jig-sawed together along the shoreline. These current and former salt ponds are a turn-of-the-century remnant of one of the region’s historical industries. They also are a reminder of the wetlands that once spanned the region. Over two-thirds of the ponds are now combined into one of the largest restoration projects on the West Coast, exemplifying challenges with restoration of fragmented habitats.
Vast restoration projects like these are taking place across the country—along with efforts related to climate change mitigation, water quality improvement, and saving species—prompt bigger-picture questions about how to maximize benefits of large-scale regional efforts.
“Decision makers, project sponsors, and the public rightly demand a defensible method and accounting of the results of expensive projects,” said Ron Thom, an emeritus scientist at PNNL and co-author on the study.
Currently, there are few requirements for restoration practitioners to add up the cumulative benefits, so evaluating the effectiveness of restored ecosystem function is often overlooked. Historically, restoration started off as a small endeavor, and only recently is it practiced at large, regional, or landscape scales. At these scales, the complexity of ecosystems means that a simple additive approach does not adequately capture change.
While the idea of maximizing operational efficiency isn’t new—it’s a core tenet of business—what is new is the application to restoration projects across large regional areas. How do you maximize benefits and sidestep common challenges practitioners face, such as fragmented funding, conflicting goals, geographic overlap, ecological complexity, and efforts siloed by jurisdictional boundaries?
That’s the shift in thinking researchers hope to spark at the national level.
Linking together small projects for bigger ecosystem restoration benefits
The team, led by PNNL’s Heida Diefenderfer, identified synergistic effects of restoration outcomes and synthesized an ecosystem-management framework supported by techniques and a toolbox for resource managers.
This framework encourages practitioners to look beyond boundaries, across landscapes, and over time, while considering the cumulative effects of projects. For example, migratory birds nesting on the shore of the lower Missouri River can be impacted by upstream river management decisions, such as flow. This is a type of a cross boundary effect—both the migratory birds and the Missouri River span lines on a map. So, if populations were managed for only a specific portion of the river, the approach could miss the forest for the trees.
“The intent is to give environmental planners, scientists, and engineers the conceptional and decision frameworks needed to plan large-scale restoration in a way that maximizes benefits, as well as monitoring tools suitable for evaluating those benefits,” said Diefenderfer.
Another example: suppose a natural resource manager is faced with restoring salmon populations in the lower Columbia River and estuary to provide habitat for threatened and endangered salmon populations? They might be confronted with a large number of management questions, such as:
- How big of an area should be restored?
- Should it be only marshes, or should it include small rivers?
- Will other species benefit?
- How do geographic boundaries influence methods?
The research team evaluated some of the country’s major restoration programs over the past several decades seeking similarities. They also sought ways to leverage positive feedback and avoid unintended consequences, such as adverse changes to water quality during restoration.
The culmination of ecosystem restoration efforts
From the Florida Everglades, to the Columbia River, to the Northeastern coastal states, the research team noticed some common effects and defined eight types of ecological responses operating in large-scale restoration, collectively referred to as “cumulative effects.” These effects help planners and scientists plan and evaluate environmental change across landscapes, time periods, and ecological systems, like food webs.
“The ideas collected here set the stage for a new era of restoration coordinated at a larger scale, recognizing synergistic and additive effects and providing broader ecological and social benefits,” said David Burdick, director of the University of New Hampshire’s Jackson Estuarine Laboratory and coauthor on the study.
In light of the upcoming United Nations Decade of Restoration (2021-2030), with efforts such as large-scale tree planting being proposed globally to mitigate climate change, the authors reasoned that the next step scientifically is to broaden the lens. Looking across landscapes will help guide strategies to leverage cumulative effects and maximize the development of ecological and habitat functions.
Evaluating restoration outcomes with cumulative effects is the focus of “Applying Cumulative Effects to Strategically Advance Large-Scale Ecosystem Restoration,” a paper published online October 29, 2020, in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, a journal of the Ecological Society of America, DOI: 10.1002/fee.2274.
The research team includes PNNL’s Heida Diefenderfer, Kate Buenau, Gary Johnson (retired), and Ronald Thom (emeritus), along with Gregory Steyer, Hilary Neckles, and Neil Ganju (U.S. Geological Survey), Matthew Harwell (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency), Andrew LoSchiavo (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers), David Burdick (University of New Hampshire), Elene Trujillo (Puget Sound Partnership), John Callaway (University of San Francisco), and Robert Twilley (Louisiana State University).
MORE NEWS FROM
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
comments 
commenting policy
Supernovae Twins Open Up New Possibilities for Precision Cosmology
Cosmologists have found a way to double the accuracy of measuring distances to supernova explosions - one of their tried-and-true tools for studying the mysterious dark energy that is making the universe expand faster and faster.
First nanoscale look at a reaction that limits the efficiency of generating clean hydrogen fuel
Transitioning to a hydrogen economy will require massive production of cheap, clean hydrogen gas for fuel and chemical feedstocks. New tools allow scientists to zoom in on a catalytic reaction that's been a bottleneck in efforts to generate hydrogen from water more efficiently.
First Detailed Look at How Charge Transfer Distorts a Molecule's Structure
When light hits certain molecules, it dislodges electrons and creates areas of positive and negative charge. An X-ray free-electron laser study has directly observed how this charge transfer affects a molecule's structure for the first time.
Suitable Spawning Habitat Awaits Salmon
Scientists at PNNL and the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation identify acres of spawning habitat in the Upper Columbia River.
Story tips: Stealthy air leak detection, carbon to chemicals and recycling goes large
ORNL story tips: Stealthy air leak detection, carbon to chemicals and recycling goes large
Blueprint for a robust quantum future
Researchers at Argonne National Laboratory, the University of Chicago and scientific organizations in Japan, Korea and Hungary have established an invaluable resource for those looking to discover new quantum systems.
Science Snapshots From Berkeley Lab
Science Snapshots From Berkeley Lab - Water purification, infant-warming device, cuff-based heart disease monitor, ancient magnetic fields
Mapping the Electronic States in an Exotic Superconductor
Scientists mapped the electronic states in an exotic superconductor. The maps point to the composition range necessary for topological superconductivity, a state that could enable more robust quantum computing.
New computer model helps brings the sun into the laboratory
Every day, the sun ejects large amounts of a hot particle soup known as plasma toward Earth where it can disrupt telecommunications satellites and damage electrical grids. Now, scientists have made a discovery that could lead to better predictions of this space weather.
Watching the Evolution of Nanostructures in Thin Films
Scientists have found a way to turn X-ray fluorescence into an ultra-high position-sensitive probe to measure nanostructures in thin films. The fluorescence reveals the evolution of nanostructures in real time with nearly atomic-level resolution, something no other technique has achieved. This allows scientists to watch nanostructures in thin films evolve with unprecedented precision and design thin films for new applications.
Department of Energy Announces $10 Million for Research on Quantum Information Science and Nuclear Physics
Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced $10 million for interdisciplinary research in Quantum Information Science (QIS) and nuclear physics.
ORNL's Sergei Kalinin elected Fellow of the Microscopy Society of America
Sergei Kalinin, a scientist and inventor at the Department of Energy's Oak Ridge National Laboratory, has been elected a Fellow of the Microscopy Society of America professional society.
DOE Awards $17.3 Million for Student and Faculty Research Opportunities and to Foster Workforce Diversity
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) today announced $17.3 million for college internships, research opportunities, and research projects that connect talented science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) students and faculty with the world-class resources at DOE's National Laboratories.
DOE's Office of Science Graduate Student Research (SCGSR) Program selects 78 outstanding U.S. graduate students
The Department of Energy's (DOE's) Office of Science has selected 78 graduate students representing 26 states for the Office of Science Graduate Student Research (SCGSR) program's 2020 Solicitation 2 cycle.
Department of Energy Announces $11 Million for Research on Quantum Information Science for Fusion Energy Sciences
Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced $11 million for ten projects in Quantum Information Science (QIS) with relevance to fusion and plasma science.
Katrin Heitmann elected spokesperson for LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration
Argonne's Katrin Heitmann has been elected the scientific spokesperson for the LSST Dark Energy Science Collaboration. This collaboration will address fundamental questions about the evolution of the universe with data from the Rubin Observatory.
Department of Energy to Provide $2 Million for Traineeship in Isotope R&D and Production
Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced up to $2 million to establish a traineeship program to advance workforce development in the field of isotope production, processing, and associated research, with preference to minority serving institutions.
Department of Energy to Provide $10 Million for Research on Data Reduction for Science
Today, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced $10 million for foundational research to address the challenges of managing and processing the increasingly massive data sets produced by today's scientific instruments, facilities, and supercomputers in order to facilitate more efficient analysis.
ORNL's Honeycutt, Horvath Named SME 2021 Outstanding Young Manufacturing Engineers
Andrew Honeycutt and Nick Horvath, machine tool researchers at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, have been selected to receive the 2021 Geoffrey Boothroyd Outstanding Young Manufacturing Engineer Award from SME, the professional manufacturing engineering association.
Department of Energy to Provide $25 Million toward Development of a Quantum Internet
Today the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) announced a plan to provide $25 million for basic research toward the development of a quantum internet.
Harvesting Energy from Light using Bio-inspired Artificial Cells
Scientists designed and connected two different artificial cells to each other to produce molecules called ATP (adenosine triphosphate).
Engineering Living Scaffolds for Building Materials
Bone and mollusk shells are composite systems that combine living cells and inorganic components. This allows them to regenerate and change structure while also being very strong and durable. Borrowing from this amazing complexity, researchers have been exploring a new class of materials called engineered living materials (ELMs).
Excavating Quantum Information Buried in Noise
Researchers developed two new methods to assess and remove error in how scientists measure quantum systems. By reducing quantum "noise" - uncertainty inherent to quantum processes - these new methods improve accuracy and precision.
How Electrons Move in a Catastrophe
Lanthanum strontium manganite (LSMO) is a widely applicable material, from magnetic tunnel junctions to solid oxide fuel cells. However, when it gets thin, its behavior changes for the worse. The reason why was not known. Now, using two theoretical methods, a team determined what happens.
When Ions and Molecules Cluster
How an ion behaves when isolated within an analytical instrument can differ from how it behaves in the environment. Now, Xue-Bin Wang at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory devised a way to bring ions and molecules together in clusters to better discover their properties and predict their behavior.
Tune in to Tetrahedral Superstructures
Shape affects how the particles fit together and, in turn, the resulting material. For the first time, a team observed the self-assembly of nanoparticles with tetrahedral shapes.
Tracing Interstellar Dust Back to the Solar System's Formation
This study is the first to confirm dust particles pre-dating the formation of our solar system. Further study of these materials will enable a deeper understanding of the processes that formed and have since altered them.
Investigating Materials that Can Go the Distance in Fusion Reactors
Future fusion reactors will require materials that can withstand extreme operating conditions, including being bombarded by high-energy neutrons at high temperatures. Scientists recently irradiated titanium diboride (TiB2) in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to better understand the effects of fusion neutrons on performance.
Better 3-D Imaging of Tumors in the Breast with Less Radiation
In breast cancer screening, an imaging technique based on nuclear medicine is currently being used as a successful secondary screening tool alongside mammography to improve the accuracy of the diagnosis. Now, a team is hoping to improve this imaging technique.
Microbes are Metabolic Specialists
Scientists can use genetic information to measure if microbes in the environment can perform specific ecological roles. Researchers recently analyzed the genomes of over 6,000 microbial species.
Spotlight
Graduate students gather virtually for summer school at PPPL
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Virtual internships for physics students present challenges, build community
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Blocking the COVID-19 Virus's Exit Strategy
Brookhaven National Laboratory
From Nashville to New Hampshire, PPPL's student interns do research, attend classes and socialize from their home computers
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Graduate student at PPPL Ian Ochs wins top Princeton University fellowship
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Chicago Public School students go beyond coding and explore artificial intelligence with Argonne National Laboratory
Argonne National Laboratory
Barbara Garcia: A first-generation college student spends summer doing research at PPPL
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Argonne organization's scholarship fund blazes STEM pathway
Argonne National Laboratory
Brookhaven Lab, Suffolk Girl Scouts Launch Patch Program
Brookhaven National Laboratory
From an acoustic levitator to a "Neutron Bloodhound" robot, hands-on research inspires PPPL's summer interns
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Brookhaven Lab Celebrates the Bright Future of its 2019 Interns
Brookhaven National Laboratory
PPPL apprenticeship program offers young people chance to earn while they learn high-tech careers
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
JSA Awards Graduate Fellowships for Research at Jefferson Lab
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility
ILSAMP Symposium showcases benefits for diverse students, STEM pipeline
Argonne National Laboratory
Integrating Scientific Computing into Science Curricula
Brookhaven National Laboratory
Students from Minnesota and Massachusetts Win DOE's 29th National Science Bowl(r)
Department of Energy, Office of Science
DOE's Science Graduate Student Research Program Selects 70 Students to Pursue Research at DOE Laboratories
Department of Energy, Office of Science
Young Women's Conference in STEM seeks to change the statistics one girl at a time
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Students team with Argonne scientists and engineers to learn about STEM careers
Argonne National Laboratory
Lynbrook High wins 2019 SLAC Regional Science Bowl competition
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
Equipping the next generation for a technological revolution
Argonne National Laboratory
Chemistry intern inspired by Argonne's real-world science
Argonne National Laboratory
Argonne intern streamlines the beamline
Argonne National Laboratory
Research on Light-Matter Interaction Could Lead to Improved Electronic and Optoelectronic Devices
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI)
Innovating Our Energy Future
Oregon State University, College of Engineering
Physics graduate student takes her thesis research to a Department of Energy national lab
University of Alabama at Birmingham
"Model" students enjoy Argonne campus life
Argonne National Laboratory
Writing Code for a More Skilled and Diverse STEM Workforce
Brookhaven National Laboratory
New graduate student summer school launches at Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
The Gridlock State
California State University (CSU) Chancellor's Office
Meet Jasmine Hatcher and Trishelle Copeland-Johnson
Brookhaven National Laboratory
Argonne hosts Modeling, Experimentation and Validation Summer School
Argonne National Laboratory
Undergraduate Students Extoll Benefits of National Laboratory Research Internships in Fusion and Plasma Science
Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory
Students affected by Hurricane Maria bring their research to SLAC
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
Brookhaven Lab Pays Tribute to 2018 Summer Interns
Brookhaven National Laboratory
CSUMB Selected to Host Architecture at Zero Competition in 2019
California State University, Monterey Bay
From Hurricane Katrina Victim to Presidential Awardee: A SUNO Professor's Award-Winning Mentoring Efforts
Brookhaven National Laboratory
Department of Energy Invests $64 Million in Advanced Nuclear Technology
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI)
Professor Miao Yu Named the Priti and Mukesh Chatter '82 Career Development Professor
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI)
2018 RHIC & AGS Annual Users' Meeting: 'Illuminating the QCD Landscape'
Brookhaven National Laboratory
High-School Students Studying Carbon-Based Nanomaterials for Cancer Drug Delivery Visit Brookhaven Lab's Nanocenter
Brookhaven National Laboratory
Argonne welcomes The Martian author Andy Weir
Argonne National Laboratory
UW Professor and Clean Energy Institute Director Daniel Schwartz Wins Highest U.S. Award for STEM Mentors
University of Washington
Creating STEM Knowledge and Innovations to Solve Global Issues Like Water, Food, and Energy
Illinois Mathematics and Science Academy (IMSA)
Professor Emily Liu Receives $1.8 Million DoE Award for Solar Power Systems Research
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI)
Celebrating 40 years of empowerment in science
Argonne National Laboratory
Showing results
0-6 Of 2215