Expert Pitch
University of Georgia

Don’t Play Chicken—Why Government Shutdowns Are Bad for the Country

7-Feb-2018 8:05 AM EST, by University of Georgia

Newswise — It’s deadline time for Congress to act on the federal budget. On Feb. 8, the continuing resolution, temporarily funding federal government operations and agencies, expires.

Katherine Willoughby, a University of Georgia faculty expert on public budgeting and finance, said it’s hard to say if there will be another budget shutdown and a fifth continuing resolution could be passed.

What’s the impact and who’s to blame? Willoughby shared a list of six things to know about a potential shutdown. 

Shutdowns weaken the government over time “Over time, government shutdowns weaken the administrative infrastructure for getting federal work done. A shutdown is more than a temporary interruption in the budget process. It is a process fracture that is the result of “brinksmanship budgeting”—a game of chicken in which opponents test each other to a breaking point for policy development. This way of doing business contributes to poor performance by halting momentum in the conduct of government programs, services, projects, analyses and reporting efforts. Brinksmanship budgeting erodes public trust,” she said.  

“In 2011, in fact, Standard & Poor’s downgraded the long-term credit of the U.S. from AAA to AA+ citing concerns about the fractious policymaking process of Congress, along with continually growing debt and the government’s fiscal performance.”

“Each shutdown, their frequency and the cumulative financial effects are tremendous. The break in fund flows stalls momentum, slows the economy, dulls employee morale and depresses public trust.”

Voters can blame themselves
“Voters are partially to blame for shutdowns. Sending elected officials to Washington with the proviso that there is to be no compromise, particularly regarding issues like immigration, allows members of Congress to get away with playing brinksmanship budgeting. Unfortunately, shutdowns do not always coincide with elections, and often voters have forgotten their suffering during a shutdown when later entering the ballot booth to re-elect their congressmen and congresswomen.”

Putting it off until March
“It could be that Congress determines it best to pass a fifth continuing resolution and then negotiate through the long list of things that remain in dispute. These include DACA that expires in March—the disagreement that precipitated the last shutdown—as well as Democratic versus Republican ideas about increases for discretionary spending that includes defense and non-defense programs, delayed disaster relief, and a whole host of other things.”

Immigration is a key issue
“If a deal cannot be reached, or a deal to make a deal before March 5, cannot be brokered, then another shutdown could occur. Lack of clarity on what is acceptable to the president regarding immigration is problematic. Resolution could come about for the opposite reasons—Congress members could agree on a way forward, be somewhat fearful that they (of whichever party) will be held accountable by voters in the next elections, and come up with an immigration solution that the president supports and will sign.”

Bad for morale
“The morale of government employees and contractors plummets with every shutdown. Furloughed employees may have to dig into savings for essentials and are not able to spend as freely for the period of a shutdown, slowing the economy. Any clients of services and programs not stipulated as essential during a shutdown will suffer. Young people thinking about going into the public service have to question engaging with a government that cannot make good on promises.”

“State and local governments must deal with the impacts too, and the effects on these governments trickles down to residents and visitors. For example, if national parks and federal historic sites are closed, states must determine if they can weather the political fallout of turning people away or pony up their own funds to keep tourist attractions open. Unfortunately, visitors traveling to these sites and then learning of a government shutdown are likely to heap their disappointment and blame on government, generally, not just the federal one.”

A history of not passing appropriation bills
“The budget considered here covers less than a third of total federal spending. That is, shutdowns regard discretionary spending, not mandatory, entitlement spending, and not interest on the debt. Discretionary spending includes defense and non-defense spending covered in 12 appropriation bills that should be passed by Congress every year and by Oct. 1. However, the last year in which Congress passed all 12 appropriation bills by the start of the fiscal year was 1997.”

Katherine Willoughby is the Golembiewski Professor of Public Administration at UGA’s School of Public and International Affairs. She has spent the last 30 years teaching, conducting research and consulting regarding public management, budgeting and finance. She has internationally recognized expertise of the legal foundations, use and effects of performance budgeting on U.S. state management, budgets and finances 

She is available to comment using UGA’s VideoLink ReadyCam studio, which is fully equipped with an HD camera, professional quality audio and lighting, electronic backdrop, recording options and IP-based transmission.

To arrange a broadcast interview, please contact Melissa Jackson, Media Relations Broadcast Coordinator, at 706-202-9033 or meljack@uga.edu.

To contact Katherine Willoughby directly, email kwilloughby@uga.edu or call 706-583-0553.

 

Filters close

Showing results

110 of 5619
Released: 19-Oct-2020 3:05 PM EDT
Experts haven’t changed their estimates for COVID-19 immunity duration, despite Trump's claim
Newswise

We rate this claim as mostly false. Infectious disease experts did not shift from saying immunity was lifelong to saying it lasted only a few months for partisan reasons. Experts haven’t changed their estimates for immunity duration, which remains unknown. Most agree that it is not a "life-time".

Released: 19-Oct-2020 2:25 PM EDT
Trump misleads on the Bidens involvement in the Burisma investigation at weekend rally
Newswise

This quote is referencing the claim alleging that Biden (then Vice President) pressed to have a prosecutor fired while the prosecutor was investigating Burisma. We rate this claim as False. Trump's statement is projecting misinformation by omiting facts, and omiting the series of events that followed the Ukranian money laundering investigation.

Newswise: Rapid disease pathogen identification a step closer
following successful UAH startup demonstration
Released: 19-Oct-2020 10:00 AM EDT
Rapid disease pathogen identification a step closer following successful UAH startup demonstration
University of Alabama Huntsville

Soon it could only take an hour to find out what pathogen is making you ill, following the successful demonstration of the world’s first multi-pathogen identification using non-amplified RNA detection by GeneCapture, a company cofounded by researchers at The University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH).

Released: 19-Oct-2020 8:55 AM EDT
Voting Rights, Election 2020, Colleges, Universities, and Us
Rutgers University-New Brunswick

Join the presidents of Rutgers University, Williams College, Berkshire Community College, and Howard University for Voting Rights, Election 2020, Colleges, Universities, and Us, a virtual conversation on Oct. 20 about voting rights, the upcoming 2020 Election, and the implications for colleges and universities.

Released: 16-Oct-2020 7:00 PM EDT
SCOTUS hearings: What Judge Barrett’s confirmation could mean
Arizona State University (ASU)

ASU law scholars explain the impact the confirmation could have on existing public health, health care and reproductive laws

Newswise: Mail-Order Prescriptions Delayed? Here’s What to Do
Released: 16-Oct-2020 4:50 PM EDT
Mail-Order Prescriptions Delayed? Here’s What to Do
Cedars-Sinai

Receiving mail-order prescriptions on time is critical during the ongoing pandemic, as older adults and people with chronic conditions are avoiding leaving their homes.

Released: 16-Oct-2020 3:10 PM EDT
New national poll: Biden leads Trump by 10
University of Massachusetts, Lowell

Former Vice President Joe Biden has a 10-point lead over President Donald Trump in the contest for the White House in a new national poll of likely voters released today by the UMass Lowell Center for Public Opinion.


Showing results

110 of 5619

close
2.34233