Pilot program would boost skilled immigration, economic growth

Cornell University
27-Jul-2020 1:00 PM EDT, by Cornell University

Newswise — ITHACA, N.Y. – Cornell Law School scholars are proposing a pilot immigration program that would target highly skilled foreign workers using a points-based selection system modeled after successful programs in Canada and Australia. The program is an incremental change with bipartisan support that they say could not only improve a broken system but spark the nation’s economic recovery from the coronavirus pandemic. 

“The last time Congress revamped our legal immigration system was in 1990. Since then the world has changed but our immigration system has not,” Stephen Yale-Loehr, professor of immigration law practice. “We think adding a points program would be one way to start overhauling our broken U.S. immigration system.” 

Yale-Loehr is the co-author with Mackenzie Eason of a new report detailing the pilot program titled “Recruiting for the Future: A Realistic Road to a Points-Tested Visa Program in the United States.”  

The co-authors will be joined by a panel of immigration experts for a webinar Monday, July 27 at 1 p.m. to discuss their report with an audience of congressional staff and immigration officials, policy experts and journalists. The webinar is open to the public; registration is required. 

Yale-Loehr and Eason propose introducing standalone legislation to establish a 10-year pilot program. Each year it would award 50,000 permanent residence visas, or green cards, to highly skilled immigrants – a 4% increase in the total number of green cards currently issued. 

A grading rubric building upon best practices in Canada and Australia – two of the most highly sought destinations for skilled foreign workers – would determine whether an applicant qualified. The rubric would award points for high levels of education; age; fluency in English or a native language; work experience; family support; and demographic considerations that would support more diverse cohorts. 

The pilot program would not impact existing U.S. immigration programs that offer green cards based on family ties, employment or humanitarian considerations. Instead of responding to employers’ short-term labor needs, however, the pilot program aims to support the nation’s long-term economic strength. Examples of potential beneficiaries might include international entrepreneurs and health workers, the co-authors said. 

The pilot program would collect detailed longitudinal data to measure its effectiveness. If it proves as efficient, transparent and low-cost as Yale-Loehr and Eason expect, after 10 years it could be made a permanent part of the U.S. immigration system. 

Though Trump’s policies have frequently been hostile toward immigrants, the co-authors said there’s a compelling economic case for encouraging immigration generally and skilled immigration in particular. 

Immigrants already add over $2 trillion to the U.S. gross domestic product every year, they said. They make up less than 15% of the U.S. population but account for more than 25% of the nation’s venture capitalists, more than 30% of its startup founders and more than 50% of its patent holders. 

“That’s just regular immigration,” Yale-Loehr said. “But the economic and fiscal benefits of skilled immigration are even more striking.” 

The scholars pointed to research showing that for every additional skilled foreign worker hired by a U.S. firm, five to seven domestic jobs are created in that same industry. Another study found that for every 1% increase in the number of foreign workers in science, technology, engineering or math fields, the wages of U.S. workers in that field rose 7-8%. 

“This is a quick way to use immigration policy to help the U.S. economy recover,” Eason said. 

Yale-Loehr and Eason said their proposal is achievable because of its modest scope, low cost and incremental legislative approach.  

Said Eason: “We think we’ve really built something that could easily be supported on both sides of the aisle.” 


For additional information, see this Cornell Chronicle story. 

Filters close

Showing results

1120 of 6018
Released: 1-Jun-2021 1:50 PM EDT
American Society of Anesthesiologists Makes Recommendations to Biden Admin.: Implement ‘No Surprises Act’ Equitably Without Improper Advantage to Health Insurers
American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA)

Today, the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) requested the Biden administration include a series of recommendations in its regulations to implement the “No Surprises Act,” the new federal surprise medical bill law, that will be implemented on January 1, 2022. ASA’s recommendations aim to ensure that the law is implemented fairly and equitably without improper benefit to health insurance companies.

26-May-2021 12:45 PM EDT
New framework to enhance national climate action and achieve global goals
International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis

A novel systematic and independent scenario framework could help policymakers assess and compare climate policies and long-term strategies across countries to support coordinated global climate action.

Showing results

1120 of 6018