Expert Pitch
University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV)

COVID-19 and the Future of Education

UNLV College of Education professor Bradley Marianno examines the role of teachers and their unions in advocating for safety and equity in fall school return plans.

The year 2020 hasn’t just been one for the history books: It’s made quite an impact on K-12 grade books as well.

As the COVID-19 pandemic drags on into another school year, the school playground has instead become a battleground for adults — teachers, parents, school administrators, public health officials, lawmakers — rowing over the future of education:

Should schools reopen? Is remote learning just as effective as in-person classes, and is the technology available to ensure equity for all students? For schools that open, is enough funding available to effectively protect teachers and students from COVID-19? For those that don’t, what about parents’ need to return to work despite the need for at-home teaching?

For answers, we turned to Bradley Marianno, a UNLV College of Education professor and expert on teachers’ unions.

Read on for an explainer of unions' influence and what's at the heart of their battles with school districts over fall instruction; the impact of economic concerns on school reopening plans; how in-person, remote, and hybrid learning impact various populations of K-12 students; and his predictions about the future of education in light of the COVID-19 pandemic.

What's at the heart of the teachers' and unions' objections to returning to school as the nation continues to grapple with the COVID-19 pandemic?

One way to think about teachers’ unions is as a type of insurance policy for teachers. Teachers will invest in their unions (i.e. pay membership dues) based on the degree to which the union organization can provide a return value, particularly in difficult and uncertain situations. COVID-19 is an unprecedentedly difficult and uncertain situation. Teachers are turning to their unions to help them voice their concerns and unions, with membership dues as the primary way in which they survive, take up the banner.  

Polling of teachers confirms that health and safety sit atop their list of concerns regarding  a return to school (see here, here, and here). Anecdotally, we heard of teachers preparing wills over the summer in case they had to return to face-to-face classroom instruction. 

Teachers’ unions, as the voice for the safety concerns, have put forward what safety measures should be in place before teachers should return to schools (see here and here for examples). These typically include the same measures we hear from health experts: adequate protective equipment, social distancing, and sterilization protocols. They also include additional items, some of which are more challenging for school districts to implement due to cost, like retrofitting HVAC systems, regular testing and contact tracing of employees, temperature screenings on campuses, and isolation rooms for sick students. Teachers’ unions aim to ensure that these measures are taken before schools are reopened. We have seen them threaten strikes, advocate for teachers to delay their decisions to return to teaching for the fall, and file lawsuits (see here, here and here). 

Many school districts across the country are allowed to decide how to proceed with course offerings this fall, leading to a variety of in-person, hybrid, and online-only plans. What role have teachers and unions played in these decisions? 

The story of school reopening is a local story. While we saw several governors take steps to close schools in the spring, the decision to reopen in the fall has largely been left to local school districts, their school boards, and their employees (see here for an analysis). 

And for the most part, reopening decisions have been pushed too late in the game, with the beginning of the school year right on the horizon. This is partly because the June and July surge in COVID-19 cases left many school leaders in a holding pattern. It’s also because local school district leadership in many places around the country were looking for more of the same guidance from state leaders about school closures that they received  in the spring to also occur in the fall. But that fall guidance never really came in most areas around the country. 

So as districts navigate the waters of reopening, they are caught between the demands of teachers’ unions, as representatives of teachers, and those of parents, which sometimes complement one another and sometimes compete. To navigate union tensions, some places have signed formal agreements (Memorandums of Understanding) to set forth the expectations of teachers. These are legally binding documents. Other places are creating their distance learning plans with union input without signing a legally binding MOU. And still others have created plans without much input from their unions. For example, Los Angeles Unified School District received heavy union input. Other locations, like Arizona, faced pressure from parents to reopen — and followed through — against objections from teachers and their unions. They now are facing protests from teachers, which will likely disrupt face-to-face learning. 

How have nationwide economic concerns impacted school reopening plans?

Economic concerns have compounded the challenge of reopening schools. Federal CARES Act funding largely went to shore up budget gaps created by the spring stay-at-home orders. Whether additional federal funding is on the way is unclear. Consequently, when school district leadership looks at the demands put forward by teachers’ unions — like retrofitting HVAC systems or implementing widespread COVID testing of staff and students — even if they agree with the measures, the fiscal situation precludes them from being able to act. Even implementing social distancing in classrooms as crowded as those in CCSD is a costly endeavor because it requires the creation of more classrooms, the hiring of more teachers, and the provision of more space. Sufficient funding could have changed the landscape of fall reopening.   

Stay-at-home orders forced parents to serve as teacher, guidance counselor, and recess monitor, giving many a newfound appreciation for the complex jobs of teachers. How might the current battle over returning to school impact that perception? 

The longer distance learning draws on, the more likely public perception regarding teachers and teachers’ unions will change (and probably not positively). We know that teachers are “essential” workers. Parents know that. Research over and over again shows that they are the most important school-based factor in student learning. If distance learning 2.0 is of higher quality than distance learning 1.0, than we might see public perception remain in support of the teachers for some time. But if not, or if distance learning drags on for a while, then be prepared to watch the reopening debate continue to play out in the school board meetings around the country. Parents are reporting worsening mental health for themselves and more behavioral problems for their children since March (see here). No doubt, the closing of schools played a role. 

We also have to remember that there is an equity issue at play here—some homes are in a better position to manage distance learning than others. Polling of teachers suggests that they are also acutely aware of this from their springtime experience trying to maintain contact with all households (see here). Perception among teachers could certainly change as well based on the degree of success they believe they are having with distance learning 2.0 and on the perceived risks of COVID-19 exposure, as case counts change. 

Which populations have been most impacted by online-only and hybrid learning?

Polling suggests that schools that serve a majority of Black and Brown students are far less likely to have access to the technology needed for remote learning (see here). Additionally, these populations of students were far less likely to be engaged in remote learning in the spring time (see here). With the suspension of some formative and summative tests, documenting the exact amount of learning lost will be difficult and tailoring instruction to help students catch up will be a challenge.  

A large group of educational researchers have called for steps to address these inequities (see here). This will not be just a “this year” problem. It will be an issue for years to come. COVID-19 has shined a light on opportunity gaps, and it will be incumbent upon educators and policymakers to direct the necessary resources to mitigating these disparities in the coming years.  

I believe we will see discussions regarding whether we should allow our special education students, homeless students, English-language learners, and other students at high risk of further learning loss to return to face-to-face instruction first. California is beginning these discussions. We may see phased reopening plans begin to include these students as the first to return so long as there are staff willing to serve them.

Filters close

Showing results

110 of 5849
Newswise:Video Embedded newswise-expert-panels-on-covid-19-pandemic-notable-excerpts-quotes-and-videos-available
Released: 18-Jun-2021 2:10 PM EDT
Newswise Expert Panels on COVID-19 Pandemic: Notable excerpts, quotes and videos available

Newswise is hosting a series of Expert Panels discussion on unique aspects of the COVID-19 pandemic. This tip sheet includes some notable quotes from the panelists.

access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 23-Jun-2021 8:00 AM EDT Released to reporters: 18-Jun-2021 11:00 AM EDT

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 23-Jun-2021 8:00 AM EDT The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Newswise:Video Embedded virtual-event-for-june-17-11am-edt-covid-19-vaccines-and-male-fertility
Released: 18-Jun-2021 8:55 AM EDT
VIDEO AND TRANSCRIPT AVAILABLE: Vaccines and Male Fertility Event for June 17, 2021

This upcoming JAMA-published study examined whether the COVID-19 vaccine impacts male fertility.

access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 22-Jun-2021 11:00 AM EDT Released to reporters: 18-Jun-2021 8:30 AM EDT

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 22-Jun-2021 11:00 AM EDT The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Released: 18-Jun-2021 7:05 AM EDT
Teamwork saves lives: COVID-19 hospital network shares key findings to improve care
Michigan Medicine - University of Michigan

Data sharing among 40 Michigan hospitals about the care and outcomes for thousands of inpatients with COVID-19 has led to reduced variation and findings that could inform care anywhere, including approaches for preventing blood clots and reducing overuse of antibiotics, as well as a risk prediction tool.

Released: 18-Jun-2021 7:05 AM EDT
One-third of older Americans delayed health care over COVID concerns
Michigan Medicine - University of Michigan

Nearly one in three Americans between the ages of 50 and 80 put off an in-person appointment for medical care in 2020 because they were worried about exposure to the novel coronavirus, new national poll data show.

Released: 17-Jun-2021 4:15 PM EDT
UNC Researchers Lead Study of Diabetes Treatment of COVID-19 Patients
University of North Carolina School of Medicine

Diabetes is one of the comorbidities most strongly associated with severe COVID-19 in the US, and data from early in the pandemic suggested individuals with type 2 diabetes faced twice the risk of death from COVID-19 and a greater risk of requiring hospitalization and intensive care. A new study shows best treatment options.

Released: 17-Jun-2021 4:10 PM EDT
Vaccination, Previous Infection, Protect Against COVID-19 gamma/P.1 Variant in Animal Model
University of Wisconsin-Madison

In a new study using variant virus recovered from one of the original travelers, researchers in the U.S. and Japan have found that vaccination with an mRNA vaccine induces antibody responses that would protect humans from infection with the gamma/P.1 variant.

Released: 17-Jun-2021 1:30 PM EDT
Hackensack Meridian Doctors, Student Help Establish Way to Prioritize Surgeries During COVID-19 lockdown
Hackensack Meridian Health

The MeNTS method of prioritizing surgeries during the height of pandemic, developed by University of Chicago, helped procedures continue during time of need

Released: 17-Jun-2021 12:55 PM EDT
‘Nanodecoy’ Therapy Binds and Neutralizes SARS-CoV-2 Virus
North Carolina State University

Nanodecoys made from human lung spheroid cells (LSCs) can bind to and neutralize SARS-CoV-2, promoting viral clearance and reducing lung injury in a macaque model of COVID-19.

Showing results

110 of 5849