New model accounts for the effect of behavior changes to predict COVID-19 cases

14-Jun-2021 2:50 PM EDT, by Brown University

Newswise — PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] -- By adding behavioral components to an infectious disease model, Brown University researchers have developed a new modeling approach that captures the peaks and valleys in new COVID-19 cases seen over the past 16 months.

The approach, published in the journal Scientific Reports, could be useful in forecasting the future trends in the current pandemic, as well as in predicting the course of future ones.

"We know that people's behavior matters in terms of how an infection is spread," said Vikas Srivastava, an assistant professor of engineering at Brown and principal investigator of the research. "We wanted to see if we could quantify those behavioral aspects, incorporate them into a model and see whether that model is able to capture waves of infection rates we saw in the U.S. and elsewhere."

A commonly used approach to modeling infectious disease transmission is what's known as an SIR model. The approach separates a population into distinct categories: susceptible, infected and recovered. The model moves people from one category to another according to two parameters. The transmissibility of the disease, along with the rate at which people contact each other, predict how quickly people move from susceptible to infected. The rate of recovery moves people from infected to recovered. ("Recovered" in these models generally means "no longer contagious," which also includes those who have died from the infection.)

The standard SIR model produces a curve with a single peak -- the one that infectious disease experts urged people to flatten through social distancing, masks and other measures that reduce virus transmission. But over the last 16 months, actual case rates in individual states, in the U.S. as a whole and in other nations didn't produce a single curve. Instead, they produced multiple waves of infection that created a significant challenge for the infectious disease modeling community, Srivastava says.

As the pandemic unfolded, Srivastava was teaching a class that included a section on infectious disease modeling in Brown's School of Engineering. He and his students were surprised to see the mismatch between model predictions and actual case rates.

"We saw cases going up and down, creating multiple peaks, but models were falling short in capturing it," Srivastava said. "That's what got us thinking about using population behavior and response as a way to explain and predict what is happening."

Srivastava worked with two Brown undergraduate students, Zachary LaJoie and Thomas Usherwood, to develop the new modeling strategy. They modified a standard SIR model to include the effects of vaccination, and also added two behavioral parameters to the model. The first, "level of caution," estimates people's tendency toward safe behavior -- social distancing, mask-wearing and other safety measures -- as reported cases increase. The parameter also captures government actions in response to rising case rates, such as closures and quarantines, that increase safe behavior. A second parameter, "sense of safety," models people's confidence in a return to pre-pandemic activities as more people get vaccinated.

The team then used an optimization algorithm to calibrate values for the new parameters based on case rates reported in the U.S. With the parameters optimized, the team found that the model accurately reproduced case rates throughout the pandemic in the U.S. as a whole and in individual states and cities.

"When we looked at New York City, for example, we saw a spike in our level of caution variable right around the same time government action went into effect in late March," LaJoie said. "Then as cases went down later on, we saw the level of caution come down, and there was another surge in cases going into the holidays."

With the model properly fit to the data, it enables insights into how the pandemic may unfold in the future. For example, the team was able to measure how different rates of vaccine uptake might affect case rates. Rising rates of vaccination could drive a reduction in cases, but they could also reduce levels of caution and increase the sense of safety among the unvaccinated. That could put an upward pressure on case rates even as vaccines are pulling them down. In fact, the model predicts scenarios where brief periods of rising infection rates occur as vaccines are rolled out, before they eventually begin to decline again.

In the U.S., for example, the model captures a short period of increasing infection in mid-April before rates began falling again. Larger surges in places like India look similar to the more extreme post-vaccination surges the model predicts. At its current rates of vaccination, the model predicts that cases in the U.S. should approach zero by August 2021.

Insights like that, the researchers say, could be useful in places where vaccination programs are just getting underway.

"When we developed the model, we focused on the U.S., but it would definitely be useful for making predictions in other places like India, Europe or South America where case rates are still pretty high," LaJoie said.

The modeling approach could also be applied to future outbreaks or pandemics.

"There's really nothing in this model that limits it only to COVID-19 as a disease," Usherwood said. "We think this has applicability to any situation where people's behavior is important, which is basically any infectious disease."

###

SEE ORIGINAL STUDY



Filters close

Showing results

110 of 6121
Released: 4-Aug-2021 1:00 PM EDT
American Society of Anesthesiologists and Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation Say Preoperative Testing for COVID-19 is Essential, Regardless of Vaccination
American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA)

All patients undergoing non-emergency surgeries or procedures should continue to have preoperative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing for SARS-CoV-2, irrespective of vaccination status, according to an updated guidance from the American Society of Anesthesiologists and Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation.

Newswise: FAU Expert Answers Questions about Delta Variant, Vaccines and Public Safety
Released: 4-Aug-2021 12:35 PM EDT
FAU Expert Answers Questions about Delta Variant, Vaccines and Public Safety
Florida Atlantic University

Florida Atlantic University’s Joanna Drowos, D.O., M.P.H., M.B.A., Schmidt College of Medicine, provides answers to some of the most frequently asked questions regarding the COVID-19 Delta variant, vaccines and public safety measures.

Released: 4-Aug-2021 11:15 AM EDT
Rehabilitation Nurses Play Critical Role in Treating Patients with Long-Term Covid-19 Symptoms
Association of Rehabilitation Nurses

A new and free webinar from the Association of Rehabilitation Nurses (ARN) and the American Nurses Association (ANA) features advice from rehabilitation nurses to the greater nursing community about care priorities and interventions for long haul COVID-19 patients.

Newswise:Video Embedded spreading-doses-of-hope-as-covid-19-cases-rise
VIDEO
Released: 4-Aug-2021 10:35 AM EDT
Spreading ‘Doses of Hope’ as COVID-19 Cases Rise
Cedars-Sinai

In an emotional new series of videos, Black medical professionals plead for viewers to get a COVID-19 vaccine.

Newswise:Video Embedded american-college-of-surgeons-urges-surgeons-to-talk-it-up-with-patients-about-covid-19-vaccination
VIDEO
Released: 4-Aug-2021 10:00 AM EDT
American College of Surgeons Urges Surgeons to “Talk It Up” with Patients About COVID-19 Vaccination
American College of Surgeons (ACS)

ACS is launching a “Talk It Up” campaign to help surgeons address patient concerns and help them understand the importance of getting vaccinated against COVID-19.

28-Jul-2021 11:15 AM EDT
LEDs Light the Way to Coronavirus Disinfection
American Institute of Physics (AIP)

LEDs are commonly used for sterilization, and in the continued effort to combat the coronavirus pandemic, LEDs can also help inactivate SARS-CoV-2. A team in Pakistan designed far-ultraviolet LEDs at a targeted wavelength of 222 nanometers, chosen both for its ability to inactivate the virus and for being safe on human skin. They based their design on the material aluminum gallium nitride, part of a set of materials called III-nitrides which are efficient, inexpensive, and environmentally friendly.

Newswise: Text-Message ‘Nudges’ Can Encourage Holdouts to Get COVID Vaccination, Study Finds
Released: 4-Aug-2021 8:50 AM EDT
Text-Message ‘Nudges’ Can Encourage Holdouts to Get COVID Vaccination, Study Finds
University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), Health Sciences

New UCLA-led research indicates that simple text messages emphasizing the easy availability of COVID-19 vaccines successfully boosted the number of people who got the shot.

Newswise: The Future of Masking Post-Vaccination
Released: 4-Aug-2021 8:45 AM EDT
The Future of Masking Post-Vaccination
Rush University Medical Center

The COVID-19 vaccine is your best defense against the virus, but when and where should you continue to wear a mask? Rush infectious disease expert Michael Lin, MD, answers questions about wearing a mask post-vaccination.

Newswise: COVID-19 Infection Rate Low Among Rural Health Care Workers
Released: 4-Aug-2021 8:40 AM EDT
COVID-19 Infection Rate Low Among Rural Health Care Workers
South Dakota State University

Antibody testing of health care workers in three rural counties in eastern South Dakota and western Minnesota showed 15% had antibodies to the novel coronavirus.


Showing results

110 of 6121

close
2.68972