Monell Chemical Senses Center

Better Measures Reveal More COVID-19 Smell Loss

16-Oct-2020 2:25 PM EDT, by Monell Chemical Senses Center

Newswise — PHILADELPHIA (October 14, 2020) – Smell loss is a frequently reported symptom of COVID-19 but reports of prevalence vary from study to study and range from 5% to 98%. With such a wide range of estimates, it is difficult to prioritize its importance for testing and treatment.

Investigators, led by the Monell Chemical Senses Center, determined in part why the reports vary so much. They reviewed existing research to determine whether the studies that used direct measures versus self-report of smell loss could explain the range of estimates. They found that with direct measures, about 77% of COVID-19 patients had smell loss versus only 44% with self-report.

Direct measures of smell ability involve having patients smell and report on actual odorants, whereas self-report methods include obtaining data through patient questionnaires, interviews, or electronic health records. Direct measures are objective whereas self-report are subjective measures of a person’s experience.

“Objective measures are a more sensitive method to identify smell loss related to COVID-19,” said first author Mackenzie E. Hannum, PhD, a postdoctoral fellow at Monell.

On the other hand, subjective measures, “while expedient during the early stages of the pandemic, underestimate the true prevalence of smell loss,” said Vicente A. Ramirez, a doctoral student at the University of California, Merced and Monell summer intern. Drs. Hannum and Ramirez are both investigators in the lab of senior author Danielle R. Reed, PhD, Associate Director at Monell.

Their research suggests subjective methodologies underestimate the true prevalence of loss of smell and that smell loss may be an effective screening method for early COVID-19 detection. The team published their findings in Chemical Senses, which is available as an open-access paper.

In addition, the team created a web resource that tracks the publication of COVID-19 and smell loss reports, which is updated weekly. (Please be patient when accessing the portal, the page takes a moment to load.) As of mid-October 2020, the online portal contains 118 studies of smell loss with close to 44,000, and this number grows daily.

The disparity between the reported prevalence of loss of smell in objective and subjective methods calls for further examination of the consequences of self-report. “Measuring people for smell loss may become as routine as measuring body temperature for fever” said Reed.

Coauthor Paule Joseph, PhD, a clinician at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) adds, “measurement of smell should be a part of all COVID-19 clinical exams and is a valuable screening tool.”

Researchers do not yet have a clear picture of the trajectory of COVID-19-induced smell loss; the team found varied reports among the studies they analyzed. Several studies reported significant improvements quickly after the onset of symptoms. However, other studies said that many patients still had not returned to a normal sense of smell more than two weeks after the beginning of smell loss.

In addition to Monell and UC, Merced, researchers from the Division of Intramural Research, National Institute of Nursing Research contributed to this research. Dr. Hannum is supported by NIH T32 funding (DC000014). Coauthor Dr. Paule Joseph is supported by the National Institute of Nursing Research (1ZIANR000035-01) and by the Office of Workforce Diversity, NIH, and the Rockefeller University Heilbrunn Nurse Scholar Award.

NOTE TO EDITORS: This open-access paper. “Objective sensory testing methods reveal a higher prevalence of olfactory loss in COVID-19–positive patients compared to subjective methods: A systematic review and meta-analysis,” is available here.

The Monell Chemical Senses Center is an independent nonprofit basic research institute based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1968, Monell‘s mission is to improve health and wellbeing by advancing the scientific understanding of taste, smell, and related senses, where our discoveries lead to improving nutritional health, diagnosing and treating disease, addressing smell and taste loss, and digitizing chemosensory data.


Filters close

Showing results

110 of 3780
Newswise: COVID-19: Dexamethasone discovery carries treatment implications
Released: 27-Oct-2020 9:00 AM EDT
COVID-19: Dexamethasone discovery carries treatment implications
University of Virginia Health System

A new discovery about how the body transports dexamethasone, a drug that can increase the survival chances of patients with severe COVID-19, suggests diabetes and other factors may reduce its potentially lifesaving effect.

Newswise: Johns Hopkins Medicine Hosts Briefing on Women’s Health
Released: 26-Oct-2020 4:00 PM EDT
Johns Hopkins Medicine Hosts Briefing on Women’s Health
Johns Hopkins Medicine

Since its inception in 1995, the mission for A Woman’s Journey has remained the same: to empower women to make the right health care decisions for their families and themselves.

Newswise: COVID-19's effect on Halloween is more trick than treat
Released: 26-Oct-2020 3:35 PM EDT
COVID-19's effect on Halloween is more trick than treat
University of Delaware

Let’s not sugarcoat it: the coronavirus (COVID-19) is hurting our holidays, even if it is, possibly, helping our teeth. A new University of Delaware study shows 42% of American households plan to consume less candy this year, and trick-or-treating could be down 41%.

Newswise: Data scientists in Chicago fill in gaps on race, ethnicity in COVID-19 testing
Released: 26-Oct-2020 3:15 PM EDT
Data scientists in Chicago fill in gaps on race, ethnicity in COVID-19 testing
DePaul University

Thousands of people are being tested for COVID-19 each day, but collecting complete demographic information, including race and ethnicity, has proven difficult. Data science researchers at DePaul University have stepped up in Chicago to help public health officials fill in this missing information.

Released: 26-Oct-2020 3:10 PM EDT
Scientists to improve food plant worker safety, product supply
Cornell University

A Cornell University-led project will use computer modeling and outreach to find optimal strategies to minimize COVID-19 cases and transmission among workers in food processing facilities, while maintaining the best possible production.

Newswise: Safety and prevention are priority for Penn State Health as COVID-19 pandemic continues
Released: 26-Oct-2020 2:10 PM EDT
Safety and prevention are priority for Penn State Health as COVID-19 pandemic continues
Penn State Health

The number of new daily cases of COVID-19 is rising sharply statewide – and the trend is reflected in central Pennsylvania and in Penn State Health’s hospitals and outpatient clinics. As the increase is not unexpected, care teams across Penn State Health remain prepared to provide care for all patients who need it – whether for COVID or any other health issue.

Newswise: Ultrasounds Show Impact of COVID-19 on the Heart
22-Oct-2020 9:35 AM EDT
Ultrasounds Show Impact of COVID-19 on the Heart
Mount Sinai Health System

International study may guide therapeutic strategies in patients with and without underlying heart conditions

Newswise: DFW COVID-19 Prevalence Study Expands
Released: 26-Oct-2020 12:20 PM EDT
DFW COVID-19 Prevalence Study Expands
UT Southwestern Medical Center

Key Points: - As North Texas braces for a second COVID wave and flu season, a major COVID-19 study by UT Southwestern and Texas Health Resources is expanding. - The study is expanding from its original invitation-only format to offer more members of Dallas and Tarrant County communities a chance to participate. - Testing in the study is still free and includes testing for active and past infections.

Released: 26-Oct-2020 12:00 PM EDT
HSS Shares Successful Strategies to Support the Health of Older Adults with Online Programs
Hospital for Special Surgery

To address health concerns of inactivity and social isolation in older adults during the pandemic, the HSS Education Institute utilized various online approaches to deliver high quality musculoskeletal health education, exercise and support programs. Claudia Zurlini, senior coordinator, Public & Patient Education at HSS, presents best practices for a successful transition to online programming at the virtual American Public Health Association meeting.

Showing results

110 of 3780