Focus on Mental Health as Cause of Mass Violence May Be Increasing Stigma

Indiana University
7-Oct-2019 4:05 PM EDT, by Indiana University

Newswise — BLOOMINGTON, Ind. -- In response to recent mass shootings and consistent public outcry, President Donald Trump's administration is considering a controversial proposal to monitor people with mental illness in hopes of preventing mass shootings. But focusing on mental illness as the root cause for mass violence may do little to solve the problem. Instead, it will increase the American public's stigmatization of people with these conditions, according to a new paper by IU Distinguished Professor of Sociology Bernice Pescosolido.

The paper, published in the October edition of the Health Affairs journal, examines trends in public perceptions of violence in people with mental illness and support for coerced treatment for these individuals across a 22-year period. The analysis found that not only had the perception of people with mental disorders as dangerous increased, the support for stripping these individuals' civil rights also increased.

The National Stigma Studies, fielded in 1996, 2006 and 2018, were topical survey modules included in the General Social Survey, the longest-running monitor of attitudes, beliefs and behaviors in American society. In the survey, respondents were given one of three vignettes describing individuals who meet clinical criteria for schizophrenia, major depression or alcohol dependence, or a fourth non-clinical "daily troubles" vignette, without being labeled as such.

Respondents were asked to measure how likely the individual described was to do something violent toward others and how likely they were to do something harmful to themselves. They were also asked if they think the individual should be forced by law to get treatment from a doctor, take prescription medication to control their behavior or be admitted to a hospital.

In general, analyses showed an increase in perceived dangerousness over the 22-year period, especially in individuals with schizophrenia. Results in 2018 showed that:

  • 60 percent of Americans thought individuals with schizophrenia were likely to be dangerous to others.
  • 68 percent of Americans thought individuals with alcohol dependence were likely to be dangerous to others.
  • 30 percent of Americans thought individuals with major depression were likely to be dangerous to others.
  • 20 percent of Americans thought individuals with "daily troubles" were likely to be dangerous to others.

Pescosolido said these results are troubling because there is little evidence that supports the notion that individuals with mental illness are more likely to commit violence. In fact, she said those with mental illnesses are more likely to be victims of violence than to be perpetrators of it. Also particularly alarming to Pescosolido is the increase in perceptions of non-clinical "daily troubles" as dangerous.

She said these shifts likely reflect the hope that medicine can solve the problems of increasing violence in America.

"In a society that's progressive, people hold medicine in very high esteem," said Pescosolido, who is also director of the Indiana Consortium for Mental Health Services Research. "But this way of thinking presumes that psychiatry can identify people who have never been violent as potential mass shooters, when the best predictor of violence is past violence, and most people with mental illness don't have violent pasts."

Support for coercive hospitalization for people with schizophrenia, already high, increased more than 10 percent between 1996 and 2018. Increased support for coercive physician treatment and hospitalization was higher among recipients who assessed individuals' potential dangerousness as more severe.

"There is a strong link between these perceptions of danger and the willingness to take away someone's civil rights or their own ability to determine whether or not they need treatment," Pescosolido said. "I believe that one way the American public tries to understand why someone did something heinous is to assume they must be 'sick.' But the majority of those who commit mass violence have not been documented to have a mental disorder."

Even though there is a link between perceived violence in mentally ill people and a willingness to strip their civil rights, she said studies have also shown that perceived violence is not significantly linked to the support of increased government funding for mental health services.

But, according to Pescosolido, even if this were the case, the country does not have enough facilities or doctors to support a government plan that rests solely on psychiatry's shoulders to solve the colossal issue of mass violence. While many doctors have rallied behind gun control and see mass violence as a public health crisis, she said they have not suggested returning to the mass confinement of people with mental health problems.

"I really hope we change the dialogue around issues of violence in our society and try to get at the root causes rather than the typical and seemingly easy answers that will not help us eliminate issues of mass violence," Pescosolido said. "What is it about isolation in our society and culture or how we treat each other that makes people want to take out other people?"

IU Research

Indiana University's world-class researchers have driven innovation and creative initiatives that matter for nearly 200 years. From curing testicular cancer to collaborating with NASA to search for life on Mars, IU has earned its reputation as a world-class research institution. Supported by $680 million last year from our partners, IU researchers are building collaborations and uncovering new solutions that improve lives in Indiana and around the globe.

Media Kit: Download clips of Pescosolido explaining the study

MEDIA CONTACT
Register for reporter access to contact details
Newswise: Focus on Mental Health as Cause of Mass Violence May Be Increasing Stigma

Credit:

Caption:

Newswise: Focus on Mental Health as Cause of Mass Violence May Be Increasing Stigma

Credit:

Caption:

CITATIONS

Health Affairs

Filters close

Showing results

110 of 5518
Released: 1-Oct-2020 1:55 PM EDT
There is no evidence to support claims that the ballots were disposed of by mail carriers in Pennsylvania
Newswise

Diamond and Silk—the former Fox Nation online personalities, claim that the recently discovered nine discarded ballots in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania were tossed out by anti-Trump United States Postal Service mail carriers. The pair shared the article on social media where it received thousands of likes and shares.

Released: 1-Oct-2020 11:50 AM EDT
Fact-checking Trump's Claim that Mail-in Ballots Will Lead to a ‘Rigged’ Election
Newswise

In the first debate between incumbant President Donald Trump and the Democratic nominee, Former Vice President Joe Biden, Trump reiterated that mail-in ballots lead to voter fraud and will lead to a rigged election. This claim is false. There is no evidence that mail-in ballots are rigging the election. "Unsolicited" mail-in ballots have been used for years in several states, with little to no evidence of voter fraud.

access_time Embargo lifts in 2 days
Embargo will expire: 1-Oct-2020 4:00 PM EDT Released to reporters: 1-Oct-2020 10:40 AM EDT

A reporter's PressPass is required to access this story until the embargo expires on 1-Oct-2020 4:00 PM EDT The Newswise PressPass gives verified journalists access to embargoed stories. Please log in to complete a presspass application. If you have not yet registered, please Register. When you fill out the registration form, please identify yourself as a reporter in order to advance to the presspass application form.

Newswise: 244478_web.jpg
Released: 30-Sep-2020 3:50 PM EDT
Friend-to-friend texting may be the most effective voter mobilization tactic during 2020 election
Data Science Institute at Columbia University

Friend-to-friend text messaging may be the new door-to-door canvassing leading up to the 2020 election.

Released: 30-Sep-2020 3:05 PM EDT
Trump's Claim That He Has the Support of Portland's Sheriff Is False
Newswise

Trump's Claim that he has the support of Portland's Sheriff is False

Released: 30-Sep-2020 2:50 PM EDT
Former Vice President Joe Biden never said that he attended Delaware State
Newswise

Biden was referring to when he announced his first Senate bid on the campus of Delaware State College in 1972.

Released: 30-Sep-2020 9:55 AM EDT
Political Polarization: Often Not as Bad as We Think
Columbia University, Mailman School of Public Health

As politics grows increasingly polarized, a new global study finds people often exaggerate political differences and negative feelings of those on the opposite side of the political divide, and this misperception can be reduced by informing them of the other side’s true feelings. The study replicates earlier research in the United States, finding the phenomenon to be generalizable across 25 countries.


Showing results

110 of 5518

close
1.66972