Elderly Women in Rural Areas Less Likely to Recover from Depression

Release Date: March 19, 2013 | By Valerie DeBenedette, HBNS Contributing WriterResearch Source: Depression Research and Treatment

KEY POINTS

* A study of elderly people in Canada found that eighty percent of those with depression recovered over the course of a year.* People who did not recover from depression tended to report more chronic diseases and have a low estimate of their own mental health.* Elderly women living in rural areas appear to be at higher risk for recurrent depression.

Newswise — Being female and living in a rural area are among several factors that predicted whether an elderly person with depression recovered over the course of a year, finds a recent study in Depression Research and Treatment. Additional risk factors included having high levels of stress, being chronically ill and having a low estimate of one’s own mental health.

“Our results suggest that when older depressive people are single or separated, have multiple chronic diseases, suffer from severe stress, report a high number of hassles, and consider themselves to be in poor mental health, they should receive special attention from health professionals,” wrote the study authors.

Furthermore, older women living in rural areas tended to suffer from recurrent bouts of depression, cycling between recovery and relapse, according to the study. Lead author Samia Mechakra-Tahiri of the Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières in Québec, Canada added, “Older women do not seem to be at greater risk of persistent depression, but do seem to suffer more from fluctuating emotional states, at least among those living in the community.”

The study followed 2752 elderly people living near Quebec, Canada over 12 months. Of the 164 people with depressive symptoms at the beginning of the study, 80 percent had recovered by the end.

Previous studies of depressed elderly people have had opposite findings, with one study showing that 73 percent of those who were depressed at the start of the study remained depressed. But, Mechakra-Tahiri explained, those studies looked at patients in medical facilities, not in their own homes or with family. This difference in results is both notable and unexpected, Mechakra-Tahiri said.

“Older adults who live in assisted living or residential units for older adults would likely score differently,” said Norman Abeles, Ph.D., professor emeritus of psychology at Michigan State University in East Lansing. People in those situations may also have more physical symptoms and cognitive problems, he noted. The link between rural living and an increased risk of depression, while known to mental health professionals, may not be more widely known, Abeles added.

“Our [earlier research] revealed that the higher probability of depression outside metropolitan areas was not explained by the age or gender composition of the sample, nor by respondents’ socioeconomic status, health status or social relationships,” said Mechakra-Tahiri. Living in a rural area may be a risk factor due to isolation and the stress of working in agriculture, with its economic uncertainty and dependence on crops and weather, she added.

TERMS OF USE: This story is protected by copyright. When reproducing any material, including interview excerpts, attribution to the Health Behavior News Service, part of the Center for Advancing Health, is required. While the information provided in this news story is from the latest peer-reviewed research, it is not intended to provide medical advice or treatment recommendations. For medical questions or concerns, please consult a health care provider.

Depression Research and Treatment: Editorial Office: [email protected]

Mechakra-Tahiri DS, et al. (2013).Pattern of change of depressive disorder over a one-year period among community-dwelling older adults in Québec, Depression Research and Treatment.